Skip to Content

Can Butter Be Substituted For Vegetable Oil In Baking

Can Butter Be Substituted For Vegetable Oil In Baking

Can Butter Be Substituted For Vegetable Oil In Baking

Butter may easily be used in place of oil for baking. Most cake recipes call for oil. However, butter has a far richer flavour. Simply melt the butter, measure it out, let it cool, and then add it to the recipe in place of the oil.

You can substitute melted coconut oil or butter in baked goods such as muffins, brownies, and cookies as a vegetable oil substitute.

IngredientsAmount of butter
Vegetable oilthree-quarters of a cup
Roux1/2 cup butter with some liquid
Palm oil1/2 cup of butter
Coconut oil8 tsp of butter
Different ingredients and the amount of butter required to substitute them

What quantities to substitute?

Substitute three-quarters of a cup of vegetable oil for every butter you need. If your recipe calls for 1 cup butter, substitute 1/2 cup butter and add some liquid until the dough comes together and moistens properly. For example, if a recipe calls for 10 tablespoons of butter, you can use about 7 1/2. If your recipe only calls for ghee, you’re more likely to get similar results when you replace the butter.

It might sound impossible, but you can substitute butter for butter in almost any recipe. You can also substitute butter in most recipes if you don’t eat dairy or are just looking for a different flavour but remember that flavour is important.

There is no hard and fast rule about the correct amount of oil for an oil change, but you can usually use about three-quarters of the amount needed in a recipe. Butter can be replaced with vegetable oil in most cases.

However, it’s important to understand the purpose of the oil in the recipe you want to substitute. The differences between butter and butter make substitution possible, but they also make it a little tricky.

Watch this video to learn about the difference between baking cake in butter and vegetable oil

Differences in food made with oil instead of butter

If you cook your recipes with vegetable oil instead of butter, remember that some cookies won’t work as well as they should unless they’re made with solid fat. Butter tortillas tend to be more tender and moist, but butter tortillas bake longer with even more crumbs.

Butter also doesn’t work well for recipes like cookies and cakes that first call for creaming or aerating butter with sugar and eggs.

In these cases, after using the butter, you can also increase the amount of yeast to encourage leavening and reduce the chance of a thick cake.

If you’re interested in Can You Grind Nuts In A Coffee Grinder, take a look at my other article.

While some substitutes can be used in equal amounts, like vegetable oil in a cake, others must be measured not to overwhelm the flavour. Since many reasons might make you consider replacing vegetable oil in a cake recipe, having these substitutes in place can be useful. Butter is an excellent substitute for vegetable oil, especially when baking cakes, muffins, cookies and pastries.

Most recipes recommend using oil for frying or roasting vegetables, and you can use oil in soups just like butter. You can use the recommended amount of butter instead of dairy butter, a vegan butter substitute, or margarine.

A good rule of thumb is to treat margarine like butter – it’s best to replace it with melted butter. Margarine, usually made from refined vegetable oil and water, loses some moisture to evaporate when heated, so using margarine can make baked goods thinner instead of fluffy.

Note that olive oil has a strong flavour, which works best with savoury baked goods like vanilla bread or cookies. This might be fine, but if you choose olive oil, make sure you want the cake to have a rich flavour. While avocado oil has a slightly more unique flavour than other oils, this flavour is not commonly found in cooking.

The oil is not emulsified; it is pure fat, so no variations or added ingredients exist. A lighter-flavoured oil is best for sweet recipes, but chocolate recipes like chocolate cake taste better with richer oils like olive and avocado.

To learn about Can You Make Rice A Roni In A Rice Cooker, check out my other article where I cover things in detail.

Which of the above is the best ingredient for making cookies?

Usually, cookies can be made with butter, so using a highly saturated oil such as coconut or palm oil (or shortening) is best. Highly saturated oils and whipped butter are suitable substitutes for shortening, fudge, and no-bake cookies.

Since these oils are much lower in saturated fat, they do not settle easily, even in the freezer. Because the amount of fat in bread or pastries affects how they rise, the closest butter substitutes to butter are highly saturated oils such as coconut or palm oil.

Using coconut oil

It’s very hard to even use coconut oil as a substitute for butter in crumbly baked goods and cookies like ladyfingers, croissants, or anything with delicate, crumbly layers. If you want it a little softer, substitute 7 tablespoons of coconut or palm oil plus 1 tablespoon of highly unsaturated oil for every 8 tablespoons (1/2 cup) of butter.

For something that needs to be drier and more crumbly, it’s easier to stick with butter (no pun intended), but you can make a non-dairy version by substituting coconut oil. You can replace the mashed avocado in equal parts with your desired amount of butter, especially if you want an alternative higher in fibre and vitamins K/C/B-5/B-6/E.

Remember that this also depends on your tastes, so as with any other substitution, feel free to research which oils you like best and pair them well with the dish you’re cooking.

Gravy, sauce, butter, vegetable oil, or animal fat can be used interchangeably when making a roux. You can use 50/50 butter and butter in recipes that call for butter – this will give you the butter flavour and moisture from the butter in the recipe.

If you want to keep the original texture of your cookies, try replacing half of the butter with vegetable oil, which still removes saturated fat. Butter and vegetable oil add moisture to recipes, prevent ingredients from sticking to each other (or to the pan), and add final texture to baked goods.

Vegetable oils provide more reliable hydration since oils stay liquid at room temperature and solidify. According to Ken Immer, president and culinary director of Culinary Health Solutions, butter is superior to vegetable oil because butter is a “whole, fresh food,” while vegetable oils are not.

According to the American Heart Association, Using vegetable oil instead of some or all of the butter you normally eat can make heart-healthy changes to your diet.

Using butter instead of butter in crusts or flatbreads is more challenging because these recipes rely on small pieces of solid butter to create air pockets, says Amy Shapiro, RDN, CDN, founder of Real Nutrition in New York.

Can I use melted butter instead of oil in the cake mix?

A neutral oil, such as canola or vegetable, is called for in most boxed cake mixes. Try replacing the oil with melted butter in a 1-to-1 ratio next time. Not only will your cake have a more buttery flavour, but it will also be firmer and denser.

What can I substitute for vegetable oil in baking?

If you don’t have any vegetable oil on hand, use a neutral high-heat oil instead. Oils such as canola, safflower, peanut, and grapeseed are all excellent alternatives. Unrefined versions can attain temperatures even greater than refined versions. (If you’re unsure what you have, look at the label).

Is Butter or Oil better for cakes?

 The Research says that butter contains “bad” cholesterol that is risky for the heart instead of vegetable oil. The cakes made with oil are generally superior to those made with butter. The texture of both seems to be different in the cake mix. Oil-based cakes tend to bake up loftier and stay moist and tender far longer than cakes made with butter.

Skip to content