How To Make Store Bought Ricotta Cheese Creamy

How To Make Store Bought Ricotta Cheese Creamy

If you want to make store-bought ricotta cheese creamy, don’t add any type of cream to it. First, dissolve 1/2 tablespoon of citric acid in the water, stir it for 4-5 minutes, and avoid continuously adding acid because the curd would not rise and settles down. Allow the curd to settle for 15 minutes. Transfer the mixture to the vessel.

Known as Instant Pot Pressure Cooker Ricotta, the creamy cottage cheese that comes out of this recipe is much better than store-bought cottage cheese, and you only really need the milk and lemon juice. To make the whipped ricotta, just throw 3/4 cup of full-fat cottage cheese and 1/4 teaspoon of each kosher salt and fresh black pepper into your food processor, and process until completely smooth, about 1 to 2 minutes. Simply whisk together 1 cup heavy cream, 2 cups full-fat milk, 1/4 teaspoon salt, and 1/2 teaspoon freshly-ground black pepper in a bowl. To make it, just combine 1 cup cottage cheese with 2 cups heavy cream, and whisk it together using a hand mixer or a whisk until it forms soft peaks.

IngredientsAmount
Full-fat cottage cheese3/4 cup
Kosher Salt and Black Pepper1/4 tsp
Heavy Cream1 cup
Full-Fat milk2 cups
Amount of ingredients required to make whipped ricotta.

If using the ricotta to make cheesecakes or filling for pasta, you want a firm texture — so let it sit to drain for at least 20 minutes. Allow ricotta to drain for 30–60 minutes, depending on how moist or dry you would like the ricotta. If you are making ricotta to use as a dip or spread, let it drain for 10-12 minutes, while if you are going to use it as a filling or for making pastries, let it drain for 20 minutes. To drain ricotta, put it into a fine-mesh strainer lined with moistened paper towels and allow it to sit for 15 minutes.

If the Ricotta that you bought at the store is extra wet, then you can use the following methods to quickly drain your ricotta. Using a rubber spatula, whisk Ricotta in your prepared strainer, scraping lightly around the sides and the bottom of the strainer, until all the excess whey has been removed from the ricotta, about 30 seconds (you should end up with at least 5 1/2 cups whey; if not, keep stirring until you get to 5 1/2 cups whey). Remove from heat and gently transfer contents into a large strainer (save the whey, see NOTE) and strain until desired texture, 5-20 minutes depending on whether you want a creamy or drier ricotta.

Learn how to make ricotta cheese

If you want ricotta closer to a traditional, dairy-only cottage cheese, heat the salt and milk to 185F. Remove from heat, and gently whisk in the acid, only one or two times around the pot, then allow to sit, undisturbed, for 20 minutes. Once the milk has reached the proper temperature, take it off the heat and stir in the citric acid and the salt. In a large, heavy-bottomed pot, bring the milk, cream, lemon juice, and salt to a vigorous simmer, stirring occasionally to avoid burning.

When making cottage cheese using just milk, I noticed that there is a small difference in the texture of cottage cheese made with lemon juice as opposed to vinegar. For purists, the most pure that we can be with milk-based ricotta, you can make the ricotta with 8 cups of full fat milk and 3 tablespoons of acid.

Skimmed milk contains less fat than full milk, so if you are making ricotta with skimmed milk, you are likely to have cheese that is less creamy in texture than ricotta made with full milk. Normally, I like to suggest a whole-milk substitute in recipes, but whole milk simply cannot be substituted in this recipe. Make sure that the milk you are using is full fat, and it is NOT organic milk or super pasteurized. The curds just will not form correctly with that kind of milk, and you will be disappointed in the results.

I have made cottage cheese many times before, and most of the standard recipes call for using full-fat milk. If you want a creamier ricotta, or if you would like to use another type of milk for health reasons. Making homemade cottage cheese works best with full fat milk, but you can make it with 2 percent as well.

If you’re interested in Does Vacuum Sealed Cheese Need To Be Refrigerated, take a look at my other article.

Milk-only cottage cheese is lighter in weight, and it most closely mimics the authentic Italian cottage cheese (which is harder to make than the typical homemade recipes). Milk, an additional bit of cream, lemon juice, and a few minutes hands-on are all you need to create the creamiest, smoothest, and tastiest homemade cottage cheese. You only need 4 simple ingredients and 30 minutes of your time (most of it hands-off) to make this easy, pillowy, creamy, and fresh-tasting cottage cheese recipe.

In only 10 minutes, the creamy ricotta is whipped to perfection and served with honey, lemon, and fresh herbs for a super-flavorful combo. In a little less than one hour, and using just 3 ingredients, you can have a nice creamy spread of cottage cheese on top of some toasty baguettes, with a sprinkle of honey. While whipped homemade cottage cheese is a simple, 10-minute recipe, it is best if you make it in advance, starting with the whipped cottage cheese.

Now that we have covered the ricotta part, for whipped ricotta, simply add the full-fat cottage cheese into a small-medium mixing bowl, and using a hand (or stand) mixer, whisk the ricotta for about 2 minutes, until smooth, light, and creamy. PLEASE NOTE: When testing out this recipe, I tried making ricotta using organic milk, and it did not work out for me in 3 different instances. If you cannot find fresh, homemade ricotta at your grocery store, you absolutely can purchase store-bought, pre-made cottage cheese, just be sure that it is made with full fat milk.

If you’re interested in How Long Can You Keep Brown Sugar, take a look at my other article.

Lactose-free milk might not be quite as creamy as the original, but it is still going to be richer, homemade cheese, much better than store-bought ricotta. While it is technically fresh cheese, it has much better flavor and texture than ricotta that you might get in a tub at the supermarket. Ricotta also happens to be one of the easiest and cost-effective cheeses to make, yielding essentially perfect results each time.

You can even wrap your cottage cheese in cheesecloth, and then use something heavy, such as a marble rolling board, to press it down, then store overnight, for ricotta paneer, cottage salata, queso fresco, or another farmstead cheese. If you would like to get rid of any excess water in your cottage cheese, put your cheese in a clean dish towel and wrap your towel around the cheese.

Because an easier homemade version starts with full fat milk instead of whey, the ricotta may get a little chalky if you overcook the curds. Milk: Ricotta cheese can be made using sheeps milk, goats milk, cows milk, or water buffalos milk, but for this recipe, it is best to use full-fat cows milk (full fat dairy). For the cost of one gallon of milk, you will have a cup of cottage cheese for use in recipes, or for a quick snack when guests arrive.

Is ricotta cheese supposed to be creamy?

An Italian whey cheese is ricotta, tastes slightly sweet, and has a creamy texture. Although it can be prepared from cow, goat, sheep, or water buffalo milk, the version you buy at the grocery store typically uses cow milk.

How do you thicken ricotta cheese?

Put a weighty object on top of the ricotta cheese wrapped in cheesecloth ( a  bowl, covered brick, etc.). One must be made use of a tiny bowl and a somewhat larger container of ricotta cheese. Cheese should be kept in the refrigerator for at least four hours, preferably overnight.

How do you strain store-bought ricotta?

Put cheesecloth in the strainer’s liner and set it over a kitchen with white cabinets paired basin. Ricotta should be added and then gently pushed and distributed into an equal layer using a rubber spatula. Refrigerate the bowl after loosely wrapping it with plastic wrap. Allow at least eight hours for the ricotta cheese to drain before serving.

Scroll to Top
Skip to content