Page Contents
How Do Barbacoa and Carnitas Differ?
Barbacoa is usually made using large cuts of meat or whole animals and slow-cooked until the meat is tender. In the US, beef is used, while in other countries such as Mexico, lamb, mutton, or goat may be used. On the other hand, Carnitas is a dish made solely with pork and is pan-fried or further cooked on a skillet.
To learn about How To Preserve Chillies, check out my article where I cover everything you need to know.
Unlike carnitas, barbacoa refers less to the meat in the recipe than to the preparation method. Although carnitas and barbacoa meat can be served similarly, many things make carnitas different.
Another difference is that carnitas is usually pork, while barbacoa is often beef or goat. In addition to the difference in cooking methods, pork and carnitas usually have different seasoning and blending methods.
What is carnitas made of?
Carnitas, like stewed pork, is made from a marbled cut of pork and cooked until it is soft enough to be pulled out and sliced. Carnitas, always pork, is cut into large pieces after cooking and fried until crispy.
When finished, the carnitas are minced or coarsely cut into “carnitas, ” meaning “small pieces of meat”. Another difference is that after a few hours of slow cooking, the minced meat for carnitas is fried or fried to make it crispy.
If you’re wondering Can You Live Off Rice, take a look at my other article after you finish this one.
Differences in cooking methods
Barbacoa is cooked slowly until soft, then grated and served, but carnitas meat is always crunchy after being minced and served. Finally, the main difference is that barbacoa is slowly baked in foil, while carnitas is usually fried over an open fire.
Two different cooking methods are slow, but Mexican barbacoa is cooked in an underground pit, while carnitas is boiled in lard. Both types of meat are slow-cooked, but Barbacoa is cooked underground, while Carnitas is cooked in a skillet.
The difference between Barbacoa and Carnitas is that Barbacoa is cooked slowly in the oven, on the stovetop, or in an earthenware pot. Traditionally, barbacoa is a prepared meat (usually made from sheep, goat or beef) steamed in an underground oven until very tender and juicy.
Instead of referring to a specific piece of meat, “barbacoa” describes the cooking method. Traditionally, barbacoa is an authentic Mexican cooking method of protein such as lamb, goat or beef, resulting in tender and juicy meat.
Barbacoa is a method of cooking meat (historically lamb or goat, although beef or pork is often used today) to produce tender and juicy results. Barbacoa is a traditional Mexican dish made from beef, pork or goat, simmered in a pit filled with charcoal until tender.
Barbacoa is a Mexican dish that slowly roasts beef, goat, lamb, pork or lamb in a pit lined with banana leaves or other natural ingredients. Barbacoa is usually made with goat meat and then slowly cooked in a moist environment (with onions, spices and lime) for several days.
The difference between barbacoa and carnitas is the type of beef used and how the carnitas are cooked at the end of the cooking process. Barbacoa can be made with beef, lamb, or goat. Barbacoa, like carnitas, is slowly cooked on the stovetop in an oven or slow cooker.
Carnitas, conversely, are usually made from pork and cut into huge chunks after being cooked and fried until crispy. Carnitas are fried until crispy after being cut into large chunks and browned in a pan.
What stands out more in terms of texture and flavour?
When it comes to texture and flavour, barbacoa tends to stand out more than carnitas, especially when compared to beef barbacoa.
Barbacoa, especially at Chipotle, stands out more than its counterparts in terms of texture and flavour. In terms of flavour and texture, barbacoa stands out more than carnitas, especially when it comes to beef barbacoa.
Chipotle barbacoa is specially made from beef, and fans love its flavour. Chipotle’s barbacoa, on the other hand, is made only from beef, and Chipotle’s barbacoa is full of flavours that customers love.
| Barbacoa | Carnitas |
| It can be made with a variety of meats (beef, lamb, and goat) | It is crunchy after being minced and then served |
| It can be prepared in an underground oven | Usually made with beef or pork |
| Softer flavour profile. Has a crunchy texture from browning after the slow-cooking process | Is crunchy after being minced and then served |
I don’t know what a Barbacoa Chipotle is. This Mexican BBQ dish is made with beef tenderloin, simmered long and slow in a delicious and spicy stew until soft, then minced and served with tortillas. Chipotle, adobo sauce, and spices fill and absorb the savoury, tart, smoky flavour of the minced meat that becomes even more tender as it cooks.
Traditionally, several types of meat can be used in Mexican barbecue, but the most popular are brisket or roast beef used in barbacoa. Barbacoa Beef is a very tender, melt-in-your-mouth, delicious, slow-cooked minced beef cooked in adobo sauce with many flavorful Mexican spices. Barbacoa is garlicky, tender, shredded beef simmered in a spicy, smoky, flavorful BBQ sauce.
Barbacoa is made from beef shoulder pieces rubbed with spices and minced fresh garlic and stewed for 8 hours until rich, tender and juicy.
Barbacoa is usually served as a main dish with beans, tortillas, rice, lettuce, avocado, salsa and guacamole. Grilled meat is traditionally served with corn tortillas, fried beans, guacamole, salsa verde and/or sour cream.
Barbacoa is usually dipped in sauce (some with added cheese), then wrapped in banana or plantain leaves, and grilled.
How is traditional BBQ made?
Traditional Mexican BBQ is made with meat wrapped in banana or agave leaves and cooked in an underground oven over high heat or hot coals. Birria uses cured meat cooked in a pot and then served with broth, barbacoa is traditionally cooked in a clay oven.
In addition to the cooking method to which the term barbacoa refers, the word can also refer to meat steamed until tender and flaky.
Chipotle describes barbacoa beef as “shredded pork free of antibiotics and hormones, seasoned with salt and pepper, juniper berries, thyme and bay leaves, braised and hand minced,” according to Chipotle.
It’s hard to choose between carnitas and barbacoa, as carnitas includes hearty, tender ground beef that can be eaten as is or accompanied by some of your favourite Mexican dishes.
Is Carnitas the Same as Barbacoa?
The carnitas and the barbacoa are not the same. The main difference is that carnitas is made of pork only, while barbacoa can be made using different meats like beef, chicken, lamb, and mutton. Carnitas also requires to be pan-fried for crispiness after hours of slow cooking, while barbacoa does not.
Are Carnitas and Pulled Pork the Same?
Not exactly, but the carnitas and pulled pork are somehow the same. Carnitas can be said as the Mexican version of pulled pork. For carnitas, usually, the pork shoulder. This part also called the pork butt is used because of the higher fat content. The fat makes the meat even juicier and tender.
What kind of meat is Barbacoa?
Barbacoa is typically hard cuts of meat that are not easy to cook and requires a slow cooking duration. It is commonly made with large cuts of meat or whole animals. It is typically a Mexican dish, and in the United States, barbacoa is usually made with beef, goat, lamb, or mutton.