Skip to Content

What Happens When Adding Yeast To Sourdough Starter

What Happens When Adding Yeast To Sourdough Starter

It is important to note that adding yeast to your starter for Sourdough does not mean that you are going to make bread out of it. If you are using a commercial yeast in place of the sourdough starter, then you need to adjust your yeast quantity accordingly. Traditionally, you do not add additional yeast to a bread dough made from a sourdough starter, although you may want to add yeast if making a quick bread. Instead of using a whole yeast packet, you crack or crumble a portion of yeast off and add that to the bread recipe.

IngredientsAmount
Instant Yeast1/8 tsp
Sourdough1 cup
Amount of ingredients required to speed up proofing inside a home-made sourdough starter.

Crushed (fresh) yeast does not have to be risen or suspended in water, you can just smashed it into the flour. Dry yeast/fresh yeast does not add anything to texture or texture, but the starter for a sourdough starter does, since it is made up of flour and water. Yes, you could use a sourdough starter in place of fresh yeast, however, then you would have to decrease the amount of flour and water used in your bread recipe to account for the flour and water contained in a sourdough starter. Switching from yeast to a sourdough starter would mean that your bread recipe would be made with 200 grams of your sourdough starter, 600 grams of flour, and 400 grams of water.

You could swap that out for similar amounts in any given recipe, and most recipes that call for 1 loaf of bread will require about this amount of yeast. Many older recipes called for even more yeast than 2 1/2 teaspoons, so by double- or triple-ing your yeast, your dough might be rising faster than you can handle. If you find the dough rising faster than you can shape it and bake it, cut back on the yeast next time you bake. The quick-acting nature of yeast means you can bake your dough in the morning, let it rise, get home from work, and be ready to bake later in the day.

If you’re interested in Can You Eat Bear Liver, take a look at my other article

Instant yeast only needs some water to be activated, so you do not have much preparation work. Instant yeast does indeed require a little bit of water to activate its dehydrated yeast kernels, but because you are using water anyway in bread recipes, this makes using instant yeast effortless. Active Dry is best used in bread machines, since it can tolerate longer periods of proofing, which Instant Yeast might not. This kind of yeast is slightly gritty compared to instant and needs activation in water or milk before being used in the recipe.

Active Dry is often called Rapid Raise, and is likely the most common yeast type used by home bakers. I use this kind of yeast in my popular easy sourdough sandwich loaf, discarded, as it does not have to activate first, and it can just drop right into the batter without any problems. If you are making the dough with dry active yeast that has not been first dissolved, you are going to end up with dough full of tiny dried yeast pellets.

Your dough will not rise well, since much of the yeast will still be enclosed, and it cannot get into the flour in your dough to feed. Too much yeast can make the dough flat, by releasing gases before the flour is ready to expand, as well as adding a flavor that is not good. If you do not add yeast to your dough, it will fail to rise unless you add an alternate leavening agent, like baking powder.

watch this video to know How to Convert Yeast Dough Recipes to be Made With Sourdough Starter

These types of recipes do not call for yeast, and typically make use of baking soda or baking powder to help it rise. Sourdough starters and yeast are used for leavingning breads, pizzas, rolls, bagels, etc. Other leavening agents may include baking soda, baking powder, eggs, etc. These are most popular for quick breads such as banana breads or pancakes.

Some starters use milk in place of water, and some starter recipes call for sugar or honey, boosting fermentation. Some bakers sometimes throw some yeast into a sourdough loaf along with their starter, for an extra fermentation kick. Adding yeast with a starter is sometimes done to a sourdough. The same steps are done with the starter, just like with them. The kick that it gives to the dough makes it knead harder, and you can pack the loaf in a bit more. If a starter is already kneaded, it is likely that you are adding it to that rather than the loaf recipe.

If you are especially tight on time, you may want to purchase pre-made packets of yeast, or you may want to throw some yeast into the dough for sourdoughs yourself, which helps the breadrise faster. Baking sourdough is a slow process, and even a little bit of yeast can make a big difference.

Sometimes, some bakers will put some yeast with their starter into a middle step in the sourdough, to keep fermentation going. As much yeast, or even small amounts, can drastically increase the quality of the bread baked in the long-simmering process of sourdough. However, occasionally, bakers will integrate starter with some yeast to enhance fermentation in sourdough baked goods. To accelerate the fermentation process in sourdough baked goods one teaspoon at a time, try adding 8 additional teaspoons of instant yeast to one cup. To speed up proofing inside a home-made sourdough starter, try adding 1/8 teaspoons of instant yeast per cup of flour.

You should allow at least twice as long as your sourdough recipes proofing time, which is important both for those large fermentations (first rising) and the second rising (after shaping). About 24 hours before you plan on starting sourdough, you will want to re-leave or re-feed your starter, making sure that it is active enough to allow your dough to rise and glow.

If you’re interested in How Long Does Homemade Rice Krispies Last, take a look at my other article

In fact, you could make your own sourdough with instant yeast. You probably noticed that the AP and bread flour are used together, but this was not supposed to be the main consideration during the fermentation process. You can use most types of flour for making sourdough starters, however, the best ones to use are dark or whole-grain rye flour, stone-ground flour, hard bread flour, or whole-wheat flour, because these fiber-rich flours have the most to give yeast something to eat — including the enriched bran and the nutritional wheat germ. If your reason for adding sourdough to a recipe is for easier digestion and increased nutritional value to the recipe (for example, if you suffer from a gluten intolerance), adding yeast would prevent the fermentation from properly occurring, and would fail in its goal of properly breaking down your flour.

What happens if I add yeast to my sourdough starter?

Consider leavening as a continuous process: the more commercial yeast you add to the dough, the quicker it will rise. Yeast bread, including sourdough, develops its best flavor during a prolonged, slow rise, so this isn’t always a good thing.

How to increase yeast in sourdough starter?

It’s common to practice for everyone, from professional bread makers to home bakers to sourdough newbies, to add a tablespoon or two of instant yeast to sourdough bread dough. Try adding 18 teaspoons of instant yeast per cup of flour to your homemade sourdough bread to make the proving process move more quickly.

Does sourdough starter need yeast?

NO, commercial yeast is not required for sourdough. A living fermented culture made from fresh flour and water is a sourdough starter. When the culture is joined, the natural yeasts present in our surroundings will start to ferment and grow. To make your bread dough rise, a minimal amount is added.