Page Contents
What Happens If You Eat Out-of-Date Mustard?
While not a perfect test, your senses are often the most reliable tools for determining whether packaged mustard is expired or spoiled. To determine if your mustard has gone bad, look for signs such as unusual texture, off-flavours, and reduced flavour. If none of these is present and you have only passed the ‘best before’ date, the mustard should be safe to eat.
By the way, if you’re interested in How To Preserve Carrots, check out my article on that.
Losing some of the mustard smell is still acceptable to consume, but as soon as you smell a bad or sour smell, it’s time to throw out that bad mustard.
It usually doesn’t take long after Best Buy expires that its texture starts to change due to ageing, but once it does, you can see the difference between bad old mustard and regular mustard.
You should remember that mustard is easy to store for months past its expiration date because it has an acidic flavour. It can last a long time, depending on the quality of the ingredients used in honey mustard and the amount of preservatives that food manufacturers add to the sauce.
When stored unopened on a shelf, not in extreme heat or cold, mustard will keep for one to two years after the date on the label or bottle, depending on whether that date is best-by. Use or before its expiration date.
To learn about Can You Use A Tea Bag Twice, check out my article where I cover everything you need to know.
American Mustard This popular mild mustard can last one to two years past its expiration date if left unopened and stored in the pantry at room temperature. While mustard will eventually spoil, most mustard lasts 2-3 years past its “use by” date, but that’s not the only sign of freshness.
Dry mustard also has an expiration date, but, like many other products, mustard can have an expiration date or an expiration date, which is simply the last date until which the manufacturer guarantees the quality of the product, not its safety.
| Mustard | Shelf life |
| American mustard | 2-3 years |
| Homemade mustard | 1 week to 1 year |
The “best before” date on the label is the manufacturer’s best guess as to when the mustard should be eaten for its best flavour and doesn’t always indicate that it will spoil before that date. The mustard best-by date is only a guide to how long you can expect the mustard’s premium flavour and normal texture to last.
The list below shows the estimated amount of time that mustard can be consumed after the expiration date under two conditions: the mustard has been stored properly, and there is no sign of spoilage.
To get the best enjoyment from purchased mustard, it is always best to consume it before the expiration date, as after this period, its taste will gradually begin to deteriorate. If the mustard looks good, but it’s already expired after about 2 or 3 years, it’s time to cut your losses and discard them to be safe.
Whether it’s been there for a month (or even a year), it’s good to know if the mustard has gone bad, how long it keeps, and how to extend its shelf life to maintain the best quality.
Should you freeze mustard?
In theory, there’s no point in freezing mustard because it’s available year-round, inexpensive, and keeps well in the refrigerator or pantry. In theory, there’s little point in freezing mustard; it’s available year-round, affordable, and has a satisfactory shelf life in the fridge or pantry.
You can freeze mustard, but the texture and taste will not be the same as freshly baked mustard. A jar or bottle of mustard can be shaken vigorously to make the contents homogeneous, but the quality will differ.
You can vigorously shake an entire bottle of mustard for several minutes to mix the ingredients, but the quality of the product will be constantly compromised. When your mustard goes bad, you must buy a new one or consider mustard substitutes.
If most of the liquid has separated, leaving the ground mustard seeds and other spices in a dry lump, or if the mustard smells bad, it’s best to throw it away.
You can fix dry mustard by mixing some vinegar or wine and separate mustard by just mixing it. Cracks on the surface of mustard mean that the quality has deteriorated so much that it makes no sense to save mustard.
The best way to store mustard
The best way to store mustard unopened is to keep it covered so that no other bacteria can enter the lid at room temperature.
Once opened, the easiest way to extend the mustard’s decomposition time is to place it in the refrigerator. It is advisable to keep the mustard open in the refrigerator so that it does not deteriorate faster and retains the taste.
The stated storage times for open mustard only refer to the best quality – the mustard’s texture, colour, or taste may change after this time. However, in most cases, it will still be usable if it has been kept refrigerated at all times, the bottle is intact, and there are no signs of spoilage (see below).
No, ground mustard in commercial packaging will not go bad, but over time it will begin to lose its potency and will not impart the expected flavour to food – the stated shelf life only applies to the best quality.
Your mustard may not go bad after a predetermined amount of time, but it won’t hold the same quality for much longer.
The trick is to learn how to tell if your mustard has gone bad and how to store it so it lasts as long as possible properly.
Even opened mustard can keep its vinegar content for up to a year if refrigerated and resealed after each use. Homemade mustards stored in the refrigerator have a shelf life of 1 week to 1 year, depending on the ingredients inside.
Honey Mustard – This sweeter, milder mustard concoction: This dessert lasts two to three years in the pantry before opening and one to two years when refrigerated.
Is it Safe to Eat Expired Mustard?
In most scenarios, eating outdated mustard has no negative consequences because eating after the best-before date has passed is okay. In the worst-case situation, you may get moderate food poisoning symptoms such as diarrhoea, nausea, and vomiting.
How Do you Know if Mustard is Bad?
Discard the jar if it shows symptoms of mould development. Same thing if the condiment began to stink. If the mustard appears in good condition but has been past its best-by date for over two or three years, it’s time to cut your losses and toss it simply to be safe.
Does Mustard go bad if not refrigerated?
You should store Mustard at room temperature to keep its quality for about 1 to 2 months. Refrigerated mustard should stay in good shape for about a year. You should check the storage temperature and shelf life of mustard before refrigeration. Many producers put storage guidelines on the label of their products.
Click here to view the visual Story version of this article.