Skip to Content

Is Coconut Milk In The Can The Same As The Carton

Is Coconut Milk In The Can The Same As The Carton

Is Coconut Milk In The Can The Same As The Carton

Coconut milk in the can is not the same as in the carton. Coconut milk in a carton is a thin liquid that comes from mixing coconut cream with water while canned coconut milk is thicker and richer tasting. Canned and carton coconut milk comes from the same source (coconut), but they are processed in different ways.

Incarnated coconut milk is usually modified from the naturally occurring coconut, and usually contains lots of sugar, water, salt, and thickeners; however, Coconut Milk — Carton, refrigerated Although Coconut Milk — Carton is dairy-free, the product has been added chemicals to create a larger volume a) (Read labels if you believe something is amiss. Canned shelf-stable coconut milk is dairy-free, this product has been traditionally heavily altered from natural coconut, usually comprising lots of water, sugar, added vitamins and minerals, sea salt, and preservatives or thickeners.

While carton coconut milk is made with coconut and water, like its canned counterpart, the canned coconut milk has a far more nuanced flavour than coconuts typical sweet, creamy taste. Canned coconut milk is more concentrated and typically used in baking, whereas carton coconut milk is more watered down and usually has added sweeteners. The biggest difference between canning vs carton coconut milk is that carton coconut milk has more fillers & is diluted a lot more, although they both start out with coconut and water as their primary ingredients.

The ingredients do vary a little bit between these two products, though they both usually start with coconut & strained water. Keep reading to see if there are more differences between the two products, and whether you can use them interchangeably.

In this case, the product has been added flavourings, thickeners, and stabilizers right out of the box, as you can see. The primary reason for this is extra water from the carton, not found in the jar.

Learn the difference between canned and carton coconut milk

The major difference is in the concentration of the coconut meat, but we are here to breakdown this a little more. The meaty parts of coconuts contain the highest amount of fat; so having a four-to-one ratio of coconut meat to coconut water, naturally, the fat is higher. Just as in dairy, cream has higher fat content compared to milk, so does coconut cream.

Just like heavy cream is the ultimate decadent dessert ingredient in the dairy world, coconut cream plays a similar role in the non-dairy world. Coconut cream can be whipped into a dairy-free version of whipped cream, and it is also used in making dairy-free ice cream. You can also use coconut cream that is canned or found in a carton, since it will have the thickness you will need for your slurry.

It also contains very little actual coconut cream; so, you cannot substitute that with creme. While the heavy cream does lack coconut flavor, it has the same dense texture of the canned version. In fact, Coconut Cream is practically like a solid when you crack the can — there is only a tiny bit of coconut water in the bottom. Coconut milk from a carton is far watered down, and it does not have that robust coconut flavour essential for curries and other Thai cooking recipes.

It is less dilutedIt is more diluted
It’s taste is not as good as the cartoned milkIt is much better in taste then canned coconut milk
It has shelf life of 2 yearsIt has a shelf life of 12+ months
Difference b/w canned and cartoned coconut milk.

Coconut water is sold popularly in cartons, and is often used by athletes because of the electrolytes in it. While it is possible to adjust the texture of watery curries using a coconut milk carton to a neutral, the carton does not have the depth of flavour needed to serve as a base for curries and a few other flavorful dishes. It is okay to use canned coconut milk in smoothies, but since it is thicker than carton coconut milk, you need to add less of it than with carton coconut milk, and may have to add some water or other liquid.

This article will go over 8 awesome examples when you would use canned coconut milk instead of carton coconut milk, as well as find you some tasty recipes that use canned coconut milk, including Thai Coconut Soup and flavorful Curry Sauce. Generally, according to Chintan Pandya, executive chef at Indian restaurant Junoon in New York, coconut milk is made by grinding or grating dried coconut, boiling it with water, straining the mixture, and using the resulting liquid. Companies grind the interiors of mature coconuts, producing a milk that is quite thick, and then pressure-press the mixture through cheesecloth to get the liquid.

If you’re interested in Can You Freeze Tuna Salad, take a look at my other article.

Usually, this same kind of preparation comes in cans, and differs greatly from cartons without milk substitutes, which are used by preppers to create milkshakes and cereals. Your favorite dairy-free alternatives typically arrive in a can and vary a lot from the non-milk replacement cartons, that cooks use for milkshakes and cereals. The carton is also a great option if you are looking for a dairy-free replacement for milk in vegan baking. In comparison, cartons of coconut milk come with a longer list of ingredients beyond coconut and water, which (depending on the brand) includes synthetic vitamins and minerals, and added flavourings, which are listed as “natural” on the labels, of which companies are not required to disclose their nature, and stabilizers.

The same ingredients standards for coconut cartons are roughly consistent across brands. In comparison, its bottled counterpart has mostly water and coconut, usually incorporating organic guar gum. True, canned coconut does list guar gum, too, and it is just as much of a thickener as locust beans and gellan gum.

It is important to read the label carefully before purchasing creamed coconut, as it usually contains additives such as high fructose corn syrup. While the little bit of sugar is ideal for cocktails, you will not want to use cream of coconut in regular cooking or baking. In the process of making coconut cream, you are using more coconut meat, which is what causes a rich, thick flavor and texture.

If you’re interested in Can You Eat Goat Meat, take a look at my other article.

This water content produces a creamier, thinner milk type, which you can substitute dairy products for in your regular meals. Just like how you choose between various dairy products for specific recipes, like heavy cream vs. full fat dairy, so too is choosing non-dairy options. You could use soy milk, almond milk, oat milk, rice milk, hemp milk, evaporated milk, and others instead.

What is coconut milk in a can?

Shredded coconut meat is simmered in water until it becomes a creamy paste, then it is filtered to remove the meat from the liquid to create canned coconut milk. Due to its inherent lack of dairy, coconut milk is a fantastic alternative to conventional milk in many different recipes.

Can I substitute canned coconut milk for carton coconut milk?

You can substitute canned coconut milk for carton coconut milk, especially for particular recipes requiring a milky flavor. However, some dishes may require a higher fat content, like coconut whipped cream. In that case, it is best not to substitute canned coconut milk with the carton one.

What is the difference between canned coconut milk and carton coconut milk?

You can easily differentiate between canned coconut milk and carton coconut milk by looking at the moisture or water content in each. The standard carton coconut milk is more diluted than canned coconut milk. Depending upon the recipe you want to cook, it is up to your personal preference what milk you wish to use when cooking.