Skip to Content

How Long Does Potato Salad Last In The Fridge

How Long Does Potato Salad Last In The Fridge

How Long Does Potato Salad Last In The Fridge

Potato salad can stay in the refrigerator for up to 3 days.  However, you should not keep potato salad for longer than a week because cold temperatures will cause the ingredients to lose moisture, making the salad soggy. The salad will have a sour, strange smell or visible signs of spoilage. 

A tossed potato salad that is been opened is likely to remain fresh for around 3 to 5 days, just like a homemade potato salad does if stored in a cooler. If potato salad is stored properly at favorable temperatures within the refrigerator, it will likely keep about 3-5 days without turning stale.

By the way, if you’re interested in Does Sugar Go Bad, check out my article on that.

Regardless if it is been made fresh or not, if your potato salad has been sitting outside in the open for too long, it is time to toss it. Potato salad needs to be eaten on-site at an event, or kept in the refrigerator for at most five days before throwing it out, in order to avoid bacteria growth and food poisoning.

You can prepare potato salad 1 to 2 days ahead and store in a sealed container in the fridge. You take one batch of potato salad, let it sit outside for two to three hours at the picnic, then bring the leftovers back home so they can be refrigerated and used the following day.

StorageShelf life
In refrigerator3 days
At room temperature1-2 days
Storage Vs Shelf life of Potatoes.

Since potato salad keeps up to five days in the fridge, you save tons of time and energy by making one large batch and dividing up the leftovers to be used over the following days. As for leftover potato salad, they will keep up to 3 months, provided you keep them stored properly, either in an airtight container or freezer-friendly plastic bag. When purchased at your local grocery store or supermarket, potatoes salads remain fresh until the date mentioned on the label, and sometimes as long as 1 to 2 days after that date.

While an average potato salad will keep for five days if kept refrigerated, other ingredients can cause rapid spoilage, like raw onions or dairy. While the average potato salad can last up to five days in the fridge, other ingredients might contribute to quicker spoilage, like dairy or raw onions. Even before the five-day mark, other factors may influence the speed at which a food will spoil, such as what ingredients are used, how it is prepared, and how much contamination it may already have.

Learn how to make potato salad

When you open up a salad, if it has lots of liquid at the bottom, it could indicate your ingredients have started spoiling. This tip may come in handy if your salad dressing has a tendency to split or crack after one to two days of storing. A useful tip for making sure the salad does not spoil too early in a meal is to consider making the salad without dressing, and adding the dressing separately before serving.

It is best to discard any leftovers if you took the salad to picnics on warm summer days. The best bet for now is to store leftovers in a freezer, this way you will be able to store the salads in great conditions until you are ready to have it again sometime in the not-so-distant future. If you are leaving the salad in the hot temperatures for longer than one hour, you are better off finishing within two days.

To learn about Does Brown Sugar Go Bad, check out my article where I cover everything you need to know.

You should toss out a salad that has been sitting at room temperature for longer than two hours, or longer, if it is more than 90degF (or 32degC). Bacteria rapidly grow in temperatures of 40degF to 140degF, so you should throw out eggs salad if you have left it out at room temperature for longer than 2 hours. If your egg salad has been stored correctly–in a sealed container in the fridge–it is safe to eat within five days. To make sure that your salad will freeze properly, the first step is to remove any hard-to-freeze ingredients, like eggs.

The same goes for frozen pasta salads, though ingredients do play a big role in the way that these foods freeze. Just like the one above, freezing potatoes, onions, eggs, herbs, and dressings separately in separate storage containers increases the chances that you can store your potatoes for longer. If your potato salad is made with mayonnaise, cream, or eggs, storage times will not be as long as expected, particularly if it is defrosted; you should take care not to let germs develop. Potatoes are not the only ingredients in a salad, and they do contain mayonnaise and eggs, which help to accelerate the spoilage process.

Storage keeps refrigerated potato salad from drying out and limits the amount of bacteria that can get to the food. Use it to keep potatoes and vegetables cool and free of problems and risk of spoilage. If you want to have mayonnaise on the potatoes, be sure that your potatoes are still hot when adding to the mix.

When your potatoes are done, strain out any excess water and put your potatoes into cool or room temperature water to keep from overcooking. Cut potato wedges into halves, put in a large bowl, and stir in the measured mayonnaise until all of the potatoes are covered. Since you bought your potatoes whole, your first step is to cut them in quarters and put the pieces into the big pan.

Let the potatoes cool down for at least 30 minutes so that the mayonnaise does not get oily while mixing it in with the salad. If you made a glut of potato salad, or simply had an overflowing tub foisted on you by some good-natured neighbor or family member, all you need to do is rinse out a lot of the mayo and pop the potatoes into the 425degF oven for about 30 minutes, turning the potatoes every 10 minutes or so, until they are looking pretty darned good.

There are a lot of different variations on the above, since plain old potatoes and mayo can just get a bit boring. Overcooked potatoes can make your salad into mashed potatoes, or thick, boring salad dressing can make your salad taste bland.

The salads texture will suffer, and it will have a much different flavor than what you are used to. Remember, once you put the salad in the fridge, it may not taste the same as it did on day one. Otherwise, you can use a quality kitchen timer that will remind you once an hour has passed, so that you reduce the risk of spoiling a perfectly prepared salad. You may not want to use foil in this situation, as foil will color your food, particularly your potatoes, making it less appealing.

These practices will keep the bacteria at bay, keep moisture out (no one wants a dry salad), keep your salad cold, and prevent any nasty smells from developing ([U.S. Department of Agriculture]).

Can old potato salad make you sick?

Unfortunately, staph bacterium spoilage is not visible. You may witness some severe signs if eating old potato salad. Symptoms include diarrhea, cramping in the stomach, nausea, and vomiting that typically appear three to six hours after eating. Properly stored, potato salad will last for 3 to 5 days in the refrigerator.

Can potato salad give you food poisoning?

When the proper temperature is not maintained, they turn potato salad into a breeding ground for foodborne pathogens like salmonella or listeria. For this reason, it’s important to keep potato salad cold. You may do this by placing the serving dish on ice or by keeping it in the fridge or cooler until right before serving.

Is potato salad better cold or warm?

Particularly if it’s being served cold, an excellent potato salad needs to be well-seasoned. Waiting until the potatoes are cool or while you’re dressing the salad won’t ever result in as much taste. The important part is to season as soon as you can.