Skip to Content

How Long Does Cheesecake Last In The Fridge

How Long Does Cheesecake Last In The Fridge

Under normal circumstances, cheesecakes will keep for 5 days when stored properly. Cheesecake that has been stored in the fridge will keep about one week before starting to be suspect. Like any food, cheesecake which has been opened, but has not been eaten, does not last very long unless stored correctly.

In case that happens, you can keep the cheesecake in the freezer for just over 3 months, and in the fridge for about 3 to 5 days. While other desserts can sit outside for hours with no problem, cheesecake needs to go into the fridge or stored in the freezer fairly quickly. If you are planning on eating cheesecake that has been frozen, remove the pie from the freezer and put in the refrigerator a day in advance.

If you are planning on eating the pie the following day, remove from the freezer and place in the refrigerator for a natural defrost. If you are not going to consume your pie all at once, you are better off letting it defrost in the refrigerator, and then cutting off what you need and bringing to room temperature. You can either re-freeze the leftovers ([JC]) or keep them in the refrigerator if you expect to eat them in a couple days. When you are ready to eat the pie, defrost the cheesecake overnight in the fridge, or 8 to 12 hours, and bring it to room temperature on the countertop two to three hours before serving.

Your third option is to use a pie cover to coat the cheesecake and prevent the cheesecake from picking up any smells from the refrigerator. You could also move the cheesecake into a sealed container, or wrap your cheesecake with foil. Store cheesecake slices in a tight-sided, airtight container to keep pieces from crushing. You may also want to split the cheesecake into smaller portions and store each in its own separate airtight container.

watch this video to know How Long Does Frosted Cake Last In The Fridge

You can also store your cheesecake using sturdy food containers rather than using plastic wrap, if you are running out. If you are planning on leaving the top of the cheesecake unadorned, you might hesitate to put the plastic wrap right over the top of the cheesecake. Meanwhile, you will want to have plastic wrap on which you can lay slices of the cheesecake before you put it into your refrigerator or freezer. Just be sure that your cheesecake does not have any flimsy toppings, like fruits or sauces, that might be affected structurally by defrosting, and then pack slices of the cheesecake into a freezer-safe bag or plastic wrap.

Then, for extra protection from cold air, place the pie into the freezer bag or container. Keep in mind, a freezer is a lot colder than a refrigerator, so you are going to have to do some extra steps to ensure the cheesecake stays fresh.

TypesFridgeFreezer
Homemede5 days2-3 months
Store-Bought3 days3 months
Shelf life of homemade and store-bought cheesecake.

The goal is to minimise the amount of moisture, so the cheesecake does not take flavors from the other items in your refrigerator. That way, when you get home and put your cheesecake into the refrigerator, it stays fresh and smells delicious for a long time. To maximize the quality and shelf life of your cheesecake, put them in the fridge ASAP after baking or purchase.

It is essential that you put your cheesecakes in the fridge immediately after taking it out of the oven. Generally, you can bake cheesecakes in advance, as the cheesecakes can be stored appropriately in a refrigerator or freezer.

Store-bought cheesecakes typically keep about one week, whereas non-baked cheesecakes last 5-7 days. Store bought cheesecake has the best chance to last longer, thanks to the use of stabilizers and commercial preservatives that many bakeries employ. Store-bought cheesecakes typically last 5([EC]) to 7([JC]) days in the refrigerator, while home-made ones are good for around 5 days([CAC]).

If you’re interested in Thawed Turkey In The Refrigerator, take a look at my other article

If you place an unopened cheesecake straight in the refrigerator once you get home, an unopened cheesecake may last between 5 to 6 days past its best-by date, or sale-by date. Unopened cheesecakes that are made fresh or frozen, or made at home, will stay good in the fridge for 6 to 8 days from their date of manufacture. Frozen cheesecakes may have slightly different flavors than fresh cheesecakes, but in terms of storage, both fresh and frozen cheesecakes will keep the same amount of time in the fridge.

Cheesecake should not just be left sitting on your countertop as the plain package of a pie; it needs to be either refrigerated or frozen. If you have any cheesecake left over from the previous evening, or want to keep it in storage for the coming days, your best option is to keep it refrigerated. If I am having guests over, and I notice there is leftover cheesecake, I like to keep it in the fridge.

After baking the perfect cheesecake, there might still be some leftovers you will want to save (lucky you!). If you are freezing the entire cheesecake for decoration and serving at a later date, you want to leave it intact.

You want to gobble your cheesecake as quickly as you can, or ice it up (more on that in a moment — keep scrolling!). In case you forget to eat it before the 7th day, test out texture, color, and aroma before eating. In case your cheesecake is frozen, letting it sit outside for at least 4 hours is a good idea until serving. If a cheesecake is kept too long in the fridge (or not wrapped well in the first place), it may lose airiness, with the texture becoming almost rubbery.

If you’re interested in How Long Are Blueberries Good In The Fridge, take a look at my other article

Also, properly wrapped keeps cheesecakes flavors intact by blocking out external smells. This will help cheesecakes remain fresh, and keep it protected from other smells from your fridge that can change the taste.

How do you keep a cheesecake fresh?

The easiest way to keep your cheesecake fresh is to store it airtight in the freezer or refrigerator, depending on your preference. You must either completely enclose the cheesecake in plastic wrap or put it in a container with a lid to keep it airtight.

Click here to view a visual representation of this story

How long does frozen cheesecake last in the fridge?

Frozen cheesecake upon thawing can last up to 5 to 6 days in the fridge. Keep no more than that as it can lose its shape and might start tasting a little different than you’d want it to. If you plan to eat it later, then it’s better to let the cheesecake stay in the fridge.

How long does cheesecake last out of the fridge?

Cheesecake can stay out of the fridge for about 4 to 6 hours. However, it’s crucial to remember that if you leave your cheesecake out of the fridge for more than six hours, it might go rotten, taste sour, and possibly give you intestinal problems.