Skip to Content

Can You Substitute Butter For Margarine In A Cookie Recipe

Can You Substitute Butter For Margarine In A Cookie Recipe

Can Butter Be Used As An Alternative To Margarine In A Cookie Recipe

You can use butter as an alternative to margarine in a cookie recipe. Therefore, for every cup of margarine in your cookie recipe, use 1 cup of unsalted butter. But be mindful, that your cookie will brown faster and with a distinctive taste of butter that margarine lacks.

Margarine can usually be used in place of butter, unless a distinct taste of butter is key to the recipe, such as in butter cookies. Margarine can be used in place of butter in cookies, but it often changes the texture and behavior of the cookie slightly. When using margarine instead of cooking oil, results can be very different from what you expect. If you replace butter with margarine in a baking recipe, cookies and other foods will brown faster.

In most cooking recipes where butter is not the main ingredient, margarine can easily replace it. Expect that when you use margarine butter, the cookies will be thinner due to too much spreading and will be crunchier than usual. If you substitute it, using salted butter will bring you closer to the taste of margarine. The result of replacing margarine with butter in the glaze will depend on which margarine you use.

With regular salted butter, you may need to add a pinch of salt when switching to margarine. Yes, you can easily replace margarine with unsalted butter just as you would regular butter. You can use margarine for its health benefits, or you can substitute it simply because you’ve run out of butter. Margarine should replace butter without further processing and make delicious cookies for you.

But what can your substitute with butter? Find out in this video.

Margarine-based cookies will be noticeably different from butter-based cookies. Use the same amount of margarine as for butter, and try to choose margarine with more fat if you don’t want the cookies to stretch too much. The higher fat content of margarine sticks means that they will produce a result much closer to a buttery cookie than canned margarine. If you don’t care too much about heart-healthy cookies, margarine on a stick will give your cookies the right texture and flavor that’s most similar to butter.

IngredientsQuantity
2 cups flour240 g
1/2 tsp salt3 g
1 cup unsalted butter227 g
1/2 cup sugar100 g
egg yolk2
2 tsp vanilla extract5 ml
 sanding sugar1/2 cup
The ingredients required to make perfect butter cookies.

While margarine melts fat compared to butter, and due to its higher water content than butter, it produces crunchy cookies. However, margarine has the same function because butter contains more water and less fat than butter. When combined with butter, the hydrogenated oils in margarine create a lighter texture that cannot be achieved with butter alone. Another thing to keep in mind is that butter burns faster than margarine.

Remember, butter has a lower melting point than margarine, so no matter what type of butter you use, it will be thinner. Generally speaking, butter makes the best quality cookies, but you can substitute margarine and it will still work. You can omit the butter completely, but your cookies will be soft and more cake-like in texture. Your cookies will still work without the butter, in fact they are healthier and less guilt-free.

If you’re interested in how to tell if almonds are bad, take a look at my other article.

Keep in mind that using is a big trade-off because obviously you won’t get the same cookie texture when the butter is missing. If your chocolate chip cookie recipe calls for 1 cup of butter, you can substitute 1 cup of margarine. If you want to substitute 1 cup of butter for 1 cup of margarine, you can use 1 cup of shortening or 1 cup of shortening with 14 teaspoons of salt.

To make up for the low fat content of margarine, add an extra tablespoon of margarine to the recipe for every cup of fat. Add 1 tablespoon of vegan butter for every 1 cup you replace with shortening. For every tablespoon of butter your recipe calls for, you can use the same amount of margarine.

Basically, if a recipe calls for butter, it’s usually best to always use butter, unless it explicitly states that it can be substituted for margarine. Recipes that call for cold hard butter, such as pie crusts or rolled dough, usually don’t work when softened margarine is substituted.

To learn about how long does Bolognese last in the fridge, check out my other article where I cover things in detail.

This is not the same as using melted margarine instead of melted butter when frying or on toast. Where butter is the main ingredient in a recipe, such as puff pastry, pie crusts, shortbread, and biscuits, these types of recipes require a certain ratio of fat to moisture, so butter should not be substituted for margarine.

Since margarine is technically the healthiest option, it’s easy to see why they should consider replacing regular butter with a margarine substitute in their cookies. Some people prefer to make cookies without butter or margarine because it reduces the amount of fat in the cookies and can be a good option if you’re on a diet.

This is only true if the variant you buy has little or no trans fat, as margarine may have more trans fat than butter in some cases. One thing to note is that margarine will contain more trans fats, which may defeat the purpose of using margarine in cookie recipes for some people.

As mentioned, a recipe that calls for margarine and uses butter will invariably change chocolate chip cookies. While the role of margarine will be the same as that of butter, the effect it will have on baked goods will be completely different. Baked margarine is a healthy substitute if you’re avoiding animal products or just want to cut costs, as margarine costs about half as much as butter.

In cookies, replacing butter and margarine, Greek yogurt often adds a creamy flavor while leaving a deliciously soft texture to your brownies. Using butter instead of margarine is the easiest and most reliable way to make your baked goods look as similar as possible. The margarine tastes great, but the texture will be a bit paler as the cookie spreads through the butter, creating crisper edges.

Margarine may contain more water and less fat, and can form thin cookies that spread (and possibly burn) during cooking. Because of this, baked goods that use margarine (unless the recipe specifically calls for it) will end up with a looser dough, and the dough will stretch too much (like cookies) and will burn faster. Butter makes cookies sticky and melts, while margarine makes cookies crispy.

Use regular margarine sticks or blocks instead of canned soft, spreadable margarine. Tub margarine can easily be substituted for pasta butter, and some people use it to cook on the stovetop, although we generally prefer butter instead of margarine in these cases.

What Makes Cookies Softer? Butter or Margarine?

Most bakers and chefs like to add butter to their baking recipes because of its outstanding taste. But margarine, due to having high water content, makes the baking texture softer and light which affects its final result as well.

Is it okay to use margarine instead of butter in baking?

Margarine can be fill in for spread in baking, yet the end result might end up being not the same as expected. Prepared products might be less sodden, harder, and consumed all the more without any problem. In the event that another butter isn’t a choice for you, go with stick margarine. Delicate or tub margarine will typically not hold up too in recipes.

Can you substitute butter for margarine in fudge?

Making a fudge, needs a great quality butter so don’t substitute margarine. Margarine contains more water. Because of this it can keep the fudge from setting up appropriately. Additionally, make certain to use only the amount called for in the recipe. A lot of anything can keep it from firming up appropriately.