Can You Replace Vegetable Oil With Butter
You can replace vegetable oil with butter in most recipes. For baking, the ratio of substituting will be one cup of butter to ⅞ cup of vegetable oil. But in some recipes butter can not be replaced, it is explicitly used. So, first, see for which recipe you are substituting.
It may sound impossible, but you can actually substitute butter for butter in just about any recipe. If your recipe only calls for ghee, you are more likely to get similar results when you change the butter. If a recipe calls for melted butter, you can usually substitute three-quarters of the butter.
Melt the butter first, then measure it for the most recent oil change. There is no hard and fast rule about the correct amount of oil for an oil change, but you can usually use three-quarters of the amount of oil needed in the recipe. For example, if a recipe calls for 10 tablespoons of butter, you can use about 7 1/2 tablespoons of butter.
Olive oil can be used as a substitute for butter in cooking, use three-quarters of a cup of olive oil for each cup of oil needed. If you use vegetable oil (or other vegetable oil) in place of olive oil in your cooking recipes, you can use a 1-to-1 ratio. You can replace every cup of butter you need with three-quarters vegetable oil.
Replace a tablespoon of vegetable oil with an equal amount of butter. If your recipe calls for 1 cup butter, substitute 1/2 cup butter and add some liquid until the dough comes together and looks properly moistened. If you want to make butter cookies, use half the amount of butter needed in recipes that call for butter, but add as much liquid as needed to make the cookies.
Butter also doesn’t work very well for recipes like cookies and cakes that first call for creaming or aerating butter with sugar and eggs. If you don’t eat dairy or are just looking for a different flavor, you can also substitute butter for butter in most recipes, but it’s important to keep taste in mind. There are a few recipes where butter works the same as butter, but replacing it somewhere is not the best idea. The differences between oil and butter make this substitution possible, but they also make it a little tricky.
If you use vegetable oil instead of butter for your recipe, be aware that some cookies won’t work as well as they should unless they’re made with solid fats. Most cake mixes call for butter, but butter adds amazing flavor. Highly saturated oils, as well as whipped butter, are often suitable butter substitutes for any type of shortening, fondant, and no-bake cookies.
| Substitutes | Amount |
| Butter | 2/3 cups |
| Margarine | 1 cup |
| Shortenings | 1 cup |
Because the amount of fat in bread or pastries affects how they rise, the closest butter substitutes to butter are highly saturated oils such as coconut or palm oil. Cookies without baking. In most cases, cookies help to make butter, so it’s best to use a highly saturated oil such as coconut or palm oil (or shortening). For most sweet recipes, you’ll want a lighter-flavored oil, but chocolate recipes like chocolate cake will taste better with richer oils like olive and avocado.
It’s very hard to even use coconut oil as a substitute for butter in crumbly baked goods and cookies like ladyfingers, croissants, or anything with delicate, crumbly layers. J. Schatzel found that coconut oil, which has similar properties of being solid when cold and liquid when hot, can be a successful substitute when using an amount of oil equal to the amount of oil needed in the recipe.
If you’re interested in how to preserve eggplant, take a look at my other article.
J. Schatzel would just blend the butter and oil into the wet cooking ingredients, or you could probably whip it up with the required sugar and mix as directed in your recipe. If you’re worried about the flavor integrity of a dish (J. Schatzel says the above substitutions don’t change flavor, but my picky hubby swears he can tell the difference when I use one substitution other than this substitution), use 1/4 cup unsweetened apple cider puree and 1/4 cup buttermilk for every cup of oil needed in the recipe works well. J. Schatzel, however, thinks that olive oil is a delicious butter crust substitute that I use for meat pies or pot pies (and my picky hubby didn’t notice any difference!). The substitute has worked well for J. Schatzel in all types of cooking recipes to date, although vegetable oil doesn’t have as many health benefits as some other possible substitutes.
These substitutes are preferred spread on bread or sprinkled on crackers and are often used in place of butter, which is also a substitute for vegetable oil. Butter works great in place of vegetable oil, especially in cooking, where it moistens the crumb and adds flavor to the final product. Butter is an excellent substitute for vegetable oil, especially when baking cakes, muffins, cookies and pastries.
Besides cakes, this butter is sometimes needed for other delicious baked goods like bread or muffins. When you replace the butter in the original recipe with baked goods like quick breads and muffins, the results will be very similar. One of our favorite and easiest substitutes is to brush bread with olive oil instead of butter. Check out our cooking oil guide for more butter substitute ideas.
For most cooking purposes, such as sautéing vegetables, you can use vegetable oil, butter, and margarine interchangeably. Most recipes recommend frying or roasting vegetables, and you can use oil in soups just as you would use butter. You can use melted coconut oil or butter as a substitute for vegetable oil in baked goods like muffins, brownies, and cookies. The main difference in substituting butter for butter is that butter is lower in fat than vegetable oil (butter is 100% fat, while butter is only around 80%).
If you’re interested in how to preserve eggs, take a look at my other article.
Margarine is usually made by combining refined vegetable oil and water, and when heated it loses some of the water to become steam, so using margarine can make baked goods thinner rather than fluffy. A good rule of thumb is to treat margarine like butter – it’s best to replace it with melted butter.
Once the butter has cooled, place it in a mixing bowl instead of adding the butter. If my favorite pie crust recipe calls for 4 ounces (1/2 cup) of butter, use only 3 ounces (1/3 cup) of canola oil.
What can I substitute for vegetable oil in the cake mix?
To have a super moist and soft cake, you can use margarine, butter, shortening, and all kinds of oil in place of vegetable oil. There may be subtle differences in consistency and taste. However, all cakes will have satisfactory baking outcomes.
What happens when you use butter instead of vegetable oil?
If you use butter instead of vegetable oil in your baking, your baked goods will have a more enriched taste as butter helps bring out a fantastic flavor. To substitute butter for oil, you just need to melt it, let it cool, and add a measured amount to your oil.
Vegetable Oil vs. Butter: which is healthier to use?
According to new scientific research, vegetable oils are high in linoleic acid and fail to reduce the risk of cardiovascular diseases, despite their low cholesterol levels. In other words, researchers found that eating vegetable oils might be worse for heart health in the long run than eating butter. Butter beats vegetable oil because it is a “whole, fresh food” and is high in minerals and vitamins B12 and A.