Skip to Content

Can You Get Sick From Eating Expired Mustard

Can You Get Sick From Eating Expired Mustard

In most cases, eating expired mustard has no consequences, as you can safely consume well beyond its best-by date. The shelf life of mustard depends on the best before date (best before), the method of storage, and the presence or absence of added ingredients. While mustards may last for up to two years on average, there are some exceptions depending on the type of mustard.

While mustard eventually goes bad, most mustards last 2-3 years past their “best-by” date, but this is not the only indicator of freshness. Thanks to vinegar and flavorings, mustards stay fresh at least a year after they are opened. At room temperature, mustard will retain its quality for approximately 1-2 months, and when kept refrigerated, should remain good for approximately one year.

An opened can of mustard should retain quality between 6 to 12 months if left in the refrigerator, and around one or two months if kept at room temperature. As long as jar is not opened, mustard keeps its quality for years; once opened, it keeps best from 6 months to one year in the refrigerator. The best way to store unopened mustard is with it sealed tightly, to prevent any other bacteria from getting into the lid, and at room temperature. As long as mustard is not opened, you will easily be able to keep it for one to two years after the labeled expiration date.

Mustard that is been sealed up and can stay refrigerated, but I would advise you to store it in a refrigerator after your first use. Mustard that has been closed and sealed is okay to store at room temperature, but after the first use, I would suggest that you place it in the refrigerator. If you do not like your mustard cold, and use it frequently enough that you do not want to store it refrigerated for the longest time, you can just keep your mustard bottle on a shelf, or any dry, cool area, at room temperature.

Unlike other foods, mustard does not benefit from, nor do you suffer from, a temperature shift when you store it in a refrigerator or freezer. Freezing mustard makes no sense, as it has quite a long shelf-life in the fridge, or even the pantry. When mustard has been sitting too long in the fridge, it will have the problem of vinegar separation from solids. Cracks on the mustard surface are an indication that the quality has degraded to a point where it is no longer worth saving mustard.

Storage PlacesShelf Life
Fridge1 year
Freezer18 months
Room Temperature1-2 months
Shelf life of mustard in different storage places.

If mustard has changed in appearance or flavor, do not eat it and purchase a new packet. Stop eating it if it gives you a burning sensation on the tongue, or it tastes particularly bitter or acidic. If the container does not have any organic growths, and the seasoning has an okay scent, then it should be safe to eat.

If the mustard has a foul odor, or if the bottle has bulged, it may contain unwanted bacteria growth. You will prevent the mustard from picking up odors from the other foods in your fridge, and the bacteria development will decrease. A can or bottle of mustard can be vigorously shaken to uniformize the contents, but the quality will not be the same. As I mentioned before, mustard does not spoil if it is not refrigerated once opened, but the quality degrades a lot more quickly.

It is recommended to keep opened mustard in the refrigerator, which helps to prevent the mustard from spoiling quickly, while also keeping its flavors intact. Meanwhile, tomato sauce and mustard may be kept in the refrigerator, but will not do any harm if left outside overnight, even after being opened. The stipulation is that the mustard is kept refrigerated at all times, and that the caps are screwed securely onto the bottles after every use. According to the Food Marketing Institute, an opened bottle of mustard can last for up to one year in the fridge or one month in the pantry.

If you’re interested in Can I Use Yeast Flakes To Make Bread, take a look at my other article

Opened mustard has a shorter shelf life, which may be as long as two years in the fridge, when it is sealed tight and kept out of the way of moisture and contaminants. Because homemade mustard does not have preservatives like store-bought mustard, the shelf life of homemade mustard can be fairly short. American Mustard This Popular Mild Mustard American Mustard This Popular can be kept one to two years past its best-by date if it is unopened and stored at room temperature in a cupboard. Dijon mustard- Because Dijon mustard has high vinegar content, unopened Dijon mustard can last two to three years in the pantry at room temperature, and for a year once opened in the refrigerator.

watch this video to know Top Health Benefits of Mustard 

Homemade mustards can last anywhere from one week to a year in the refrigerator, depending on packaging and ingredients used. Generally, unopened Dijon mustard has a shelf life of about two or three years after the printed expiration date on the label. An unopened bottle or can of mustard will be around 1 to 2 years past its expiration or best-by date.

While mustard can be labeled as having a Best-By date or Best-Used-By Date, that is just when a manufacturer is going to guarantee a products quality, not its safety, like with a lot of other foods. Whether or not it is been sitting around for a month (or even a year), it is helpful to know whether mustard goes bad, how long it will last, and how you can prolong the shelf life of your mustard so that you can maintain its best qualities. The trick is knowing how to tell if mustard has gone bad, and how to store it correctly so that it can last as long as possible.

If you’re interested in Best Substitute For Creole Mustard, take a look at my other article

If you leave homemade mustard on the counter too long, not only does it lose flavor, it starts separating at a rapid pace. While commercially packaged ground mustard does not spoil, it does lose flavor and strength over time, so it is recommended that you use it in a specific amount of time in order to achieve optimal flavor.

In a worst-case scenario, eating expired mustard can result in food poisoning symptoms including diarrhea, nausea, and vomiting. Honey Mustard — This blend of honey and mustard may last for two to three years in a pantry if not opened, or for one to two years once opened, stored in a refrigerator.

Can I use expired ground mustard?

Summary. Even after its expiration date, mustard is a food that has a long shelf life and can be used. It can be kept in the refrigerator or pantry, while freezing is a less usual way to store it. But over time, its quality will deteriorate.

Click here to view a visual representation of this article

How long is mustard good for after expiration date?

Mustard can last for a few months beyond its expiration date. How long mustard lasts depends on several factors, including the type of mustard, how it was stored, and the date of expiration. However, it’s best to consume it before the expiration date or within few months of it as it might start losing its shape and quality.

How to tell if mustard is bad?

First, check the expiration date on the mustard. If it is past the date, then the mustard is probably bad. Second, take a look at the mustard. If it is discolored or has changed consistency, then it is probably bad. Finally, smell the mustard. If it has a sour or off smell, then it is bad.