Skip to Content

Can You Cook Dead Crawfish

Can You Cook Dead Crawfish

Can You Cook Dead Crawfish

Crawfish are usually sold cooked, so they don’t need to be alive when cooked. It is said that cooked crawfish with straight tails were dead before cooking. It is also unknown how long the fish had been dead and how it was stored. So, it is best to avoid crawfish.

Some seem to be wondering whether or not eating dead crawfish is safe, and the answer is YES: You can eat them with no health risks. Those who consume crawfish on a regular basis say that the risk of getting sick eating dead crawfish is not the only reason to avoid them. You should never purchase or eat dead crawfish/crayfish; after death, crawfish quickly decompose and release toxins, and eating the decomposing shellfish can cause serious stomach pain, food poisoning, and even hospitalization. If you eat those dead crawfish, you can potentially get sick. Also, make sure you wash your hands immediately after handling any dead crawfish, and also with any other food, which can contain bacteria that can cause food poisoning.

By the way, if you’re interested in Can Jam Go Bad, check out my article on that.

If you notice any signs of rot, like slimy skin or dark spots on the shell, throw out the infected crawfish immediately. After washing and cleaning, do not leave the crawfish covered in water, because it needs air to remain alive.

Can you cook dead CrawfishShelf life
It is sold cooked so they don’t need to be alive when cookedIn refrigerator no more then 2 days
Cooked crawfish with straight tails were dead before cookingAt room temperature Up to 4 days
Can you cook dead Crawfish and its shelf life.

Before boiling the crawfish, all crawfish chefs will tell you to wash it in plain water until the water that is drained is clean. If you are doing this whole boiling the crawfish thing correctly, you will have a splattered hands full of intestines, with the juices running down your arms. When you are attending a crawfish boil, or eating the mounds of the stuff in the restaurants, a lot of people will simply pull the tails out, squeeze the meat out, and eat that, leaving behind a head of crawfish.

Learn how to eat Crawfish

First-time consumers of whole, boiled, spicy crawfish are usually warned to avoid the tail-on, and only eat those that have curled tails. The theory goes that cooked crawfish with straight tails are dead prior to cooking, and, not knowing how long an animal has been dead or how they are stored, is best avoided. If a cooked crawfish has a straight tail, that means that it was dead before the boiling process, and will have an off-tasting.

When you pick up a dead crawfish or lobster on your own, you know it is alive when you pick it up, and it is ready to go in a flash. If you are not harvesting the crawfish yourself, but rather buying it, then the best thing to do is throw away dead ones, as you will never know how long they were dead. If you caught the crawfish yourself and all were still alive, and you consumed them within an hour or so of taking them, you are probably fine eating the ones that were dead. Likewise, if you try to eat uncooked, dead crawfish, you are likely to find that you are sick before you even get this far.

To learn about Can Hummus Go Bad, check out my article where I cover everything you need to know.

You, or your cook, might use plenty of herbs and spices in the cooking process, but it is no way of masking the stench of a crawfish that was dead before you started cooking it. Crawfish that is dead before it is placed into a pan still will smell sour, or like it is going to be bad, even with all of the added spices the chef has available. Crawfish that are already cooked should never be left out on a counter, because this will accelerate decomposition of the meat.

If you are going to store cooked crawfish, put it into a sealed container, and make sure you consume it within 3-4 days. Then, freeze whole crawfish as fast as possible, cooked crawfish are very perishable, so the longer they have to freeze, the greater chance they will spoil. As long as you replace ice when needed, you will be able to keep your crawfish on ice for a few days without killing it — just remember, the fresher they are, the better the taste.

Some frozen crawfish might require thawing before cooking, and others you can cook straight from the freezer. Freshly caught crawfish are typically eaten raw, whereas frozen crawfish are defrosted and served either warm or cold.

Once cooked, the crab/crawfish can be stored for another 3-4 days, both alone and cooked into several delicious dishes. As mentioned at the beginning of this article, you need to purchase crawfish/crayfish and keep them alive before cooking. Stored live in a refrigerator for 1 -2 days, or 3-4 days if cooked, crawfish otherwise must be kept frozen up to 3 months to ensure best quality and flavor. You should plan to buy 3-5 pounds of live crawfish for each person for each meal, or one pound of tails, fresh or frozen, for feeding 3 people.

Based on the 15% meat yield, 6-7 pounds of live crawfish would provide 1 pound of peel-and-eat tails. When you are feeling comfortable enough to pick up your first crawfish, go with the largest one you can find–it will have the most meat–with the curved tail. When you look at the crawfish, you will see its natural waistline, as it were, and its natural waistline is the place where you want to cut it.

Inspecting a Crawfish Tail A crabfish to see whether or not it is alive when cooked is the traditional way of telling whether or not it is alive when cooked. Although there was no attempt at measuring safety or quality factors in the baseline studies, these findings disprove the myth that the observation of a straight tail in boiling crawfish is a sign of the animals being alive at the time it was cooked. A basic study suggests that the old adage of avoiding straight-tailed crawfish in crawfish boiling, as a means to ensuring safety and quality, may be unreliable, and it certainly has little or nothing to do with the animals living condition at the time it was cooked. Research conducted by LSUs AgCenter has shown no differences in tail curledness between crawfish that are alive when they are cooked versus those that are dead.

Once they are crimson, about 10-15 minutes later, take the still-living crawfish out of the boiling water and immerse your cooked crawfish into the iced water. A couple of ice cubes will help to cool down the crawfish, as well as allowing the moisture to escape, keeping the crawfish moist.

What are the health benefits of crawfish?

Crawfish is rich in the B range of vitamins. Additionally, there is a good supply of selenium as well as iron. These are vital minerals that are difficult to obtain in a regular diet. There is a disadvantage also. The presence of cholesterol is not seen as a positive factor. Finally, the presence of proteins in crawfish is an advantage for the body.

How do you know if crawfish are spoiled?

Never consume crawfish that is mealy, mushy, easily rip apart, or has an unnatural color or flavor. These symptoms suggest that the crawfish was already dead before cooking. Cooking crawfish in stews or etouffee can occasionally cause the meat to discolor or turn “blue.” The meat is actually in perfect condition.

Can I cook dead lobster?

Typically, the response is in the affirmative. Even if the texture and flavor aren’t quite as perfect, if the lobster is cooked within a day or so—again, depending on the temperatures and storage conditions of the dead lobster—it should still be safe to consume.