Skip to Content

Can I Use Butter Instead Of Vegetable Oil In The Cake

Can I Use Butter Instead Of Vegetable Oil In The Cake

Can I Use Butter Instead Of Vegetable Oil In The Cake

You can use butter instead of oil in the cake. However, it is not recommended because it does not give the same result. Butter is an easy substitute for vegetable oil in the cake, and it usually provides a notable upgrade in flavor as well. Butter gives a softer texture to the cake.

When you substitute vegetable oil for butter in the pie recipes calling for it, there are some things that come with that. You will have to taste it to believe it, but it seems to me a cake made with butter rather than butter does not quite taste the same. Using butter instead of butter actually makes a huge difference to your cakes structure, texture, and flavor.

Oil is needed for stability in cake structure, whereas butter can be substituted for oil and still result in a beautifully-tasting pie. If you are using butter in the mix, there is no difference in terms of flavour. I would still not recommend using olive oil, because that could really mess up your cakes taste. If you have never used oil replacements in your pie before, go for it; you might like how it changes the flavor, texture, and nutritional profile of the baked good.

Coconut oil is ideal for pie-mix recipes, producing a moist, puffy pie that makes you wonder why you ever used vegetable oil in the first place. Once you get coconut oil in a liquid form, begin using it the same way as you would use regular cake oil. Yes, you can use coconut oil in a cake mix, but remember that it is high in saturated fat, according to the Mayo Clinic. While habits are hard to break, especially when it comes to baking, the truth is that there are plenty of other types of fats that you can substitute for vegetable oils.

Learn the difference between butter and vegetable oil

Fats can be used in place of conventional cooking oils–just substitute an equal amount of vegetable or canola oil with extra virgin olive oil. Some of the more common alternatives to vegetable oil in pie crusts are crushed fruits, coconut oil, and other types of oils, along with butter. In this post, you will learn about the things that can be used instead of vegetable oil as well as the best way to use them for the best results for moist, tasty cakes. While for many of us butter will always be the fat to go with our cakes, butter definitely has its appeal, and it can often be a high-quality substitute.

Amount of ButterAmount of Olive Oil
10 tsp7 1/2 tsp
1 cup3/4 cup
1/4 cup3 tsp
Amount of olive required to substitute different amounts of butter.

Butter is the classic replacement for vegetable oil in all kinds of recipes, and butter works beautifully in pie making. I found I could easily replace butter with butter, and oil with melted butter, for making cakes and cupcakes, without losing any of the flavour. Since I am not a baker, I had to replace the butter and oil that I used with different products in order to get the same taste in my cakes, cookies, and pies. The great thing about my substitutes is I still get to keep my cakes and muffins looking and feeling like they did. Read more on Can I Substitute Butter For Vegetable Oil In Cookies, and let us know what you think.

Basically, you can take any pie recipe out there and replace your vegetable oil with any one of the ten alternatives found in this guide. Most boxed mixes require two or three additional ingredients, including water, eggs, and vegetable oil, that are there to tie the ingredients together, adding additional moisture to ensure a perfect pie. If you are using oil, margarine, or shortening in your cake mix, follow the directions on how much oil you are using, and then melt and chill your oil, margarine, or shortening before starting. Use the same quantity specified in the directions (for example, if it calls for 1/3 cup of butter, use 5 1/ 3 tablespoons of butter).

If you’re interested in How to know if mayo has expired, take a look at my other article.

For example, if a recipe calls for 10 tablespoons of butter, you could use around 7 1/2 tablespoons of oil. If you are substituting butter for butter in a baking recipe, you would need to use 3*4 cups of oil for the amount of butter that you are using. There is really no hard-and-fast rule on the correct amount of oil to replace butter, but generally speaking, you can use around three-quarters the amount of butter the recipe calls for. For example, if a recipe calls for 1 cup (225 grams) of butter, you could substitute it with 3/4 cup (180 grams) of olive oil.

You can use butter and oil in recipes calling for butter in a 50/50 ratio — that way, you will get a buttery flavor, as well as moisture from the oils in the recipe. You will want to use 80 percent of the butters weight in butter as butter, and fill the difference with another liquid like milk or sour cream. The butter will simply make for a more basic dough, one that is thicker and does not have that bouncy texture that a buttery dough has. Just substitute equal amount of oil for butter and bake your cakes, muffins, cookies, etc. You will notice your cakes are puffier and better tasting with butter than any other kind of oil.

Cakes made with butter are generally softer and more moist, but oil cakes tend to rise higher and have more uniform crumbs. The primary role of butter in baking is to impart richness and tenderness, and tenderness is greater in baked goods using butter. A solid fat, butter adds wonderful flavor to baked goods, which is not as strong as something like olive oil.

Unless you are specifically instructed, it is always best to use butter instead of margarine as the solid fat for your baked goods. Fats inhibit the production of gluten, and because vegetable oils contain no water, you are less likely to accidentally get a hard, cake-crunched crust. While the all-fat replacement is surprising, keep in mind that not having any fat in your butter is going to give you a dense baked good. You can make your pie recipes more nutrient-dense by using fat-free substitutes to oil, such as vegetable and fruit purees, according to AHA.

If you’re interested in Can I Substitute Soy Sauce For Tamari, take a look at my other article.

Linked with lowering LDL (orbad) cholesterol and reduced risk for heart disease, olive oil may also work as an alternative to vegetable oil in your cake mixes, according to Harvard Health Publishing. In fact, butter contains 80 percent fat, while oil contains 100 percent; replacing butter with oil increases the fat content in Betty Crocker cake mixes. In fact, we found that replacing butter with butter in dense cakes like carrot cake has really good effects on the flavor of the end product. Beranbaum says if you are going to store your pie cold–if, say, it has a cream cheese topping, which needs to be kept cold (same goes for pies topped with fruit)–it is best to use oil.

What happens if you use butter instead of oil in the cake?

Butter is the best option if you want a delicate texture for your cake. In contrast to oil, which typically results in a coarser and more open crumb in the finished product, solid fats provide a considerably smaller crumb with a lot finer texture.

Is it better to use butter or vegetable oil in the cake?

You should use vegetable oil as it creates a more moist cake. This is because oil remains liquid at room temperature, while butter may solidify. Liquid contributes to the softness in the cake and explains why cakes with oil are more moister than cakes with butter.

How much butter should I use instead of vegetable oil in cake mix?

You can substitute butter for vegetable oil using the same amount specified in the recipe directions. For instance, if the recipe calls for 1/3 cup of oil, you should use five 1/3 tablespoons of butter. Then, you should melt it down and let it cool for a while before using.