Page Contents
Can I Substitute Vegetable Oil For Butter In Cookies
You can substitute vegetable oil for butter in cookies. Since most of these are fats, they can be used as a great alternative to each other while making any type of cookies. For one cup of butter, use 3/4 cup of vegetable oil.
When choosing the vegetable oil for this recipe, check the labels on your vegetable oil containers if you are trying to cut back on saturated fat. Replacing butter with certain types of vegetable oils may reduce saturated fat levels in baked cookies. If you want to maintain the texture of the original cookies, try replacing half the butter with butter, which will reduce saturated fat anyway. You can cut back on the oil to 3 tablespoons per cup if you want to keep your fat levels in your recipes intact.
For example, if a recipe calls for 10 tablespoons of butter, you could use around 7 1/2 tablespoons of oil. Use the same amount as specified in the directions (for instance, if it calls for 1/3 cup oil, use 5 1/3 tablespoons of butter). If the recipe calls for 1 cup butter, replace with 1/2 cup of butter, adding the liquids until the dough comes together and looks adequately moist.
If you would like to use butter to make cookies, use half of the amount of butter in recipes calling for butter, but add the liquid to taste if necessary for making cookies. There is really no hard-and-fast rule on how much butter is a good substitute for oil, but generally speaking, you can use around three-quarters the amount of butter called for in the recipe. Olive oil can be used in place of butter in baking, using three-quarters of a cup of olive oil for each cup of butter called for. You may want to use the 1:1 ratio if you are replacing olive oil with vegetable oil (or another cooking oil) in a baking recipe.
You will have to use slightly more flour, as the vegetable oil will not soak into the dough the way butter does. If you are planning on making cakes, breads, or cookies, then butter is what you should use in place of butter. If you are baking cookies for a crowd, you will want to use butter instead of oil, as it will melt quicker and distribute more evenly. No-bake cookies — In most cases, the butter helps cookies set, so you want to use highly saturated butter such as coconut or palm oil (or shorten).
You can substitute coconut oil in place of either melted butter as called for in the cupcake recipes, or the solid oil called for in cookie recipes. It can even be melted together with sugar to create a leavening effect, which is what is responsible for giving cookies their shapes.
| Amount of butter | Substitute |
| 10 tsp | 7 1/2 tsp of oil |
| 5 1/3 cup | 1/2 cup of oil |
| 1/2 cup | 1 cup of oil |
Cocoa butter can also add richness and thickness in recipes, but it sets up extra firm and is not so easily found in stores. It includes everything from canola and vegetable oils, to flaxseed, olive, and avocado oils.
Using vegetable oils like canola oil in your bakes helps to keep your cakes from drying out, and you will find that vegetable oil is an ingredient in a lot of recipes, and it is also a staple in boxed cake mixes. Canola oil will keep moisture and fat in your recipes, but will not contribute a lot in the way of leavening.
It may sound impossible, but it is actually possible to substitute butter with oil for nearly every kind of recipe. This is actually a pretty simple answer, and there are a couple main reasons why you may wish to substitute something else (even if it is not butter) instead of butter. There are things like butter-flavored Crisco, which are used as a direct substitute, but I suspect this is not what you are looking for in your answer. The answer is that, yes, butter or shortening can be used interchangeably in baked goods, and they can be used as one-to-one substitutions.
J. Schatzel will simply stir both the butter and the shortening into the wet ingredients in her baking, or you could likely just whisk it into the sugar called for and stir as directed by her recipe.
With a similar nature, being solid when cold, liquid when hot, J. Schatzel has found that coconut oil is a successful substitute if using the same amount of the oil to equal the amount of butter called for in a recipe. If you are cooking for dinner, and a recipe calls for melting butter in the pot, simply use the same amount of cooking oil. If the recipe calls for melting butter on its own, you are more likely to get a similar result by substituting butter. If you are baking with oils in place of butter in a recipe, then you have to remember that some cookies do not perform the way they are supposed to when not made with a solid fat.
If you’re interested in Can totinos party pizza be made I’m microwave?, take a look at my other article.
While an entirely fat-free substitute is incredible, just remember the absence of fat in oil will give you denser baked goods. Coconut oil does not help leavening, so your muffins and cookies are likely to have shorter, denser bites than normal. The good thing about butter replacements in baked goods is you get a little bit more flexibility, as you do not need to match a high smoke point for the oil you are using (as in cooking).
Oil is not the only butter substitute for baking, but it is the most common one, and it is easy to make. In most cases, vegetable oil can replace butter. But it is important to know the purpose of the butter in the recipe that you are trying to substitute. When trying to replace one cup of butter with a cup of oil, it is important to note which of those properties butter may also offer, and also which of those properties you might not get from oil.
For most sweet recipes, you will want to use an oil that has lighter flavor, but recipes that are chocolaty, such as chocolate cakes, will be better off using a heavier oil, such as olive oil and avocado. FYI — I love using canola oil when making cookies that do not call for butter, because of its neutral taste and low saturated fat. It adds a nice texture as well, but keep in mind your cookies will spread out more because butter has a higher fluid content. While butter will add a nice buttery taste to your baked goods, it will create a slightly different texture because of its lower fat and higher water content.
If you’re interested in What To Do If I Accidentally Swallowed A Cherry Pit, take a look at my other article.
If you would like it a little more softer, replace seven tablespoons coconut or palm oil plus one tablespoon highly unsaturated butter per eight tablespoons (1/2 cup) butter. You can substitute dairy butter, a dairy-free butter alternative, or margarine with the suggested amount of oil.
Is it better to make cookies with butter or oil?
Oil is more butter than butter, which has air gaps that help it maintain its structure. It really can’t be changed from the way it was. Not to add that baking cookies with flavored oil like olive oil may result in little off-putting baked goods. Of course, you might anticipate softer dough.
Can we use vegetable oil instead of butter in cookies?
If butter is unavailable, you can easily use vegetable oil for baking your cookies. Even though vegetable oil works better for cooking muffins and quick bread, you can use it for baking cookies as well. Ideally, you should add 3/4 cup vegetable oil for every cup of butter.
Is vegetable oil better than butter for baking cookies?
Yes, vegetable oil is better than butter in helping you bake moist cookies. This is because oil remains liquid at room temperature while there is a chance that butter may solidify. In other words, vegetable oil can make tender and moist yet enriched cookies compared to those made with butter.