Skip to Content

Can I Substitute Ketchup For Tomato Paste

Can I Substitute Ketchup For Tomato Paste

Yes, it is possible to substitute ketchup for tomato sauce, but only if tomato sauce is not a major component in a recipe. If it is a major ingredient, such as in Italian cooking, switching to ketchup will change the flavor of the dish drastically, making it more savoury. This is because ketchup changes the flavor of the recipe since ketchup is made with sugar and vinegar, which are two things that are greatly lacking in tomato sauce. Although tomato sauce is a lot thinner than tomato paste, and contains additional sugar, you can still use it in a pinch instead of tomato sauce.

Tomato paste is the sweeter, thicker compressed version of both tomato sauce and tomato puree, used in making tomato sauce. Mixing tomato ketchup with tomato sauce results in a little bit of that bold flavour profile that tomato sauce produces in many dishes. Same big flavor from tomatoes, and although it is not quite as thick as tomato sauce, you still will need double as much to get the same flavor amount of paste.

Watch this video to learn about the substitutes of Tomato paste

If a recipe you are using calls for extra water, skip it, since your sauce will still be thinner than a regular tomato sauce. To use another substitute, use a 1/2 to 3/4 cup of tomato paste mixed with a 1/2 to 1/4 cup of water per 1 cup sauce that you would use in a recipe. Keep in mind, the recipe will not be quite as thick as if using tomato paste, so you may need some additional time on the stovetop to bring down the sauce.

Because tomato paste is thinner and has more water, you may have to reduce the sauce longer on the stovetop than you normally would to get the right thickness. In recipes calling for larger amounts of the paste, reduce your sauce by half by boiling before adding to your mixture. For 1 tbsp tomato paste, use 2 tbsp of pureed tomatoes or salsa mixed with 1/4 tsp sugar, removing 1 tbsp from other liquids in the recipe.

IngredientsAmount
Pureed Tomatoes2 tsp
Sugar1/4 tsp
Salsa2 tsp
Ingredients required to make substitute for tomato paste.

To thicken tomato puree, you will have to simmer it, stirring continuously, until reduced and thickened. As with canned tomatoes, plain puree can be cooked over low heat until you get the thickness you want. Although a little more work, raw tomatoes can be turned into a simple puree if no canned tomatoes or tomato products are available.

Similar to tomato sauce, canned tomatoes are less concentrated than tomato paste, so you will have to double up on the quantity of canned tomatoes used to get the flavours right. If you want just to get some tomato flavor in a dish, and you do not want paste to thicken things, then check out these canned products. Not only will you have the reigns to the canned tomato products that you never knew you needed, you will have a few super-substitutes to the tomato paste that will complement your recipes perfectly. Whether you are looking to boost the color, texture, or flavor in a recipe requiring tomato paste, here are the recommended chef-recommended substitutes to tomato paste you can use depending on your personal needs for the specific recipe.

You may be a bit surprised by this recommendation, but yes, if you do not have any other options, tomato sauce can be used in place of tomato paste. Fresh tomatoes from the grocery store or local farmers market may also be used in place of tomato paste in certain instances; however, since fresh tomatoes have a considerable amount of water, it might not be perfect all the time. As a final option, and since time is money in this society, we can save time by peeling tomatoes and crushing them for making a sauce if we purchase canned whole tomatoes, though obviously, the flavors would never quite match those provided by a few good fresh tomatoes.

You can make quick tomato puree by peeling and crushing one of your fresh tomatoes (whether or not you remove the seeds is up to you) and simmering for about 10 minutes. Tomato puree may even taste slightly more like authentic tomatoes than tomato sauce, depending on the dish and how much of it you want and use. If you are buying prepared tomato sauce, it is best to stick to a simple tomato sauce instead of one flavored with other spices, such as basil–just use the sauce and add the fresh or dried basil to the dish yourself, as it will be more aromatic and flavourful this way. These three options work just fine in the place of tomato paste, though they are a bit different in flavor and texture, so you need to adjust the quantities.

Marinara sauce has a similar texture as tomato paste already, but it should be used in recipes only when the other ingredients of the marinara–especially Italian seasoning–will not interfere or overwhelm whatever you are cooking.

If you choose to cut it back, you will want to keep heat low, stir often, and use shorter cooking times compared to cutting the tomatoes. If the resulting puree seems more liquidy than a typical tomato sauce, simply strain out any excess liquid, or simmer the mixture until it is to your desired texture. If you really are using tomato soup as a substitute, keep in mind that you will have to cut back on other liquid ingredients called for in the recipe. When mixing the tamarind concentrate with water over low heat to make a tomato soup substitute, it is best to taste and season the mixture to your liking.

If you’re interested in Benefits Of Drinking Rice Water, take a look at my other article

The following substitutions will not replace tomato sauce if you are making pasta dishes, but will provide satisfactory results if the tomato sauce is mixed in to a Crockpot recipe, casserole, or something like that just needs a little bit of the flavor of tomatoes. There is no single right way to make tomato paste: Some recipes call for mashing tomatoes in a blender before boiling, while others call for boiling on the stove until reduced to half, then spreading the mixture out onto a baking sheet and popping it into the oven to further reduce.

If you’re interested in How To Cook Serena Lasagne Sheets., take a look at my other article

Use two or three tablespoons of diced tomatoes for each tablespoon of paste called for in a recipe. Ketchup contains vinegar, sugar, and spices, so adding tomato paste to your favorite recipes changes the flavor profile. While the flavor profile may change drastically if you use too much ketchup, you can include some additional spices to help get that desired taste. A completely acceptable substitute is made by cooking strained, skinned tomatoes down until reduced and thickened to the texture of a paste.

What can I use instead of Tomato paste to thicken?

You can use Cornstarch in the place of Tomato paste as a thickening agent. This works great to thicken your soup, pasta mixture, or curry but does not give a taste similar to tomatoes. Just carefully sprinkle the cornstarch into the soup so it doesn’t clump.

Can I substitute tomato paste for ketchup in a recipe?

While ketchup and tomato paste are both made from tomatoes, they are not interchangeable in recipes. Ketchup is made from a blend of tomatoes, vinegar, spices, and sugar, while tomato paste is made from tomatoes that have been cooked down and strained to remove the water and seeds. This cooking process concentrates the flavor of the tomatoes, making tomato paste much more concentrated and flavorful than ketchup.

Is ketchup similar to tomato paste?

Tomato paste and ketchup are both made from tomatoes, but they have different textures and flavors. Tomato paste is thick and concentrated, while ketchup is thinner and has a sweeter taste. So, while ketchup and tomato paste are both made from tomatoes, they are not the same thing. Ketchup is thinner and has a sweeter flavor, while tomato paste is thicker and has a more concentrated flavor.