Clicky Skip to Content

Can I Substitute Canola Oil For Vegetable Oil In Baking

Can I Substitute Canola Oil For Vegetable Oil In Baking

Can I Substitute Canola Oil For Vegetable Oil In Baking

You can use canola oil instead of vegetable oil in baking. However, you need to reduce the amount of sugar used in your recipe. Canola oil has a neutral flavor and a high smoke point, making it a good choice for baking. It adds moisture and richness to your baked goods. 

It is typical to use canola oil in most baking recipes, but you can swap out apple sauce for it, one-for-one. While using applesauce cuts calories, the texture of baked goods becomes a lot softer if you replace all of the butter. The beauty of substituting butter for butter in baked goods is you get a little bit more flexibility because you do not need to match the highest smoking point of your oil (like you would when baking).

Both canola and vegetable oils are typically cheap and are good for baked goods and cooking due to their neutral flavors and high smoke points. Although vegetable oil and canola oil really do have a distinct taste, in baked goods, canola oil is supposed to have a very neutral taste. Like olive oil, canola oil may even be used in place of vegetable oil in the cake, since it does not have the same fat and cholesterol content.

If the recipe calls for vegetable or canola oil, then you absolutely need to replace these oils with gourmet, extra-virgin olive oil. You can use a ratio of 1-to-1 if you are replacing the olive oil for vegetable (or other cooking) oil in a baking recipe. If a baking recipe calls for eight tablespoons of butter, you would replace with six tablespoons of olive oil. You can include extra virgin olive oil in baked recipes calling for butter, and you automatically make the recipe healthier, as olive oil is lower in saturated fats than butter.

You can use rendered coconut oil or butter as a 1 to 1 replacement for vegetable oils in baked goods such as muffins, cakes, and cookies. Another viable alternative to vegetable oil is avocado oil, as you can use it to fry, saute, bake, and all of that.

Learn can you substitute canola oil for vegetable oil

Canola is a great vegetable oil substitute because it can be used in deep-frying, sauteing, baking, and even salad dressings, as it gets a relatively neutral flavor and a similar texture to that of vegetable oils. Peanut oil can substitute Canola oil for making stir-fries, is an excellent substitute for fry-frying overall, and is an ideal choice to add flavour to any Asian-inspired recipes. Even though coconut oil does not have a neutral taste, it is still used for frying in cuisine.

Even though avocado oil has a bit more of a distinctive taste compared to the others, the taste does not come out as much in baking. Avocado oil is unrefined, rich in healthy fats, Vitamin E, and has a high smoke point, meaning that it is great for roasting. Its extremely high smoke point is ideal for frying recipes such as garlic chips, in which you can even use leftover oil afterwards. Olive oil has a smoke-point of about 350oF (176oC), which is the usual cooking temperature for many recipes, especially baking-focused ones.

Avocado OilVegetable oil
Peanut soyVegetable oil
Safflower oilVegetable Oil
OlivesVegetable oil
Types of oils and there catogary.

The smoke points for these oils are pretty similar as well (within 50deg or so), so this should not impact your products much, either — just know the differences. Both oils are ideal, and they do have similar smoke points, and you can then have both oils on hand in the kitchen, and use both to cook with. Most oils are good to room temperature, unless you keep your kitchen hot and you have cooking oils in bulk.

While it is easy to blend canola and non-unintended oils together in the sauteing and baking process, it might not be so easy in the baking process. Whether you are roasting chicken or peanuts, baking Hummingbird Pie, making an appealing stir-fry, or whipping up a simple vinaigrette, you can use canola oil instead of vegetable oil, or vice versa. Both soybean and canola oil are capable of withstanding the high temperatures required in baking, and neither oil significantly changes the texture or flavor of foods when used in baking as a replacement for vegetable oil. Both vegetable and canola oils are neutral in taste, as opposed to olive and nut oils, which carry definite flavors that may overwhelm your recipes or leave a strange taste in your mouth.

If you’re interested in How To Thicken Coconut Milk, take a look at my other article.

Other oils that may fall into the category of vegetable oils include those made from avocados, corn, safflower, peanuts, soy, sunflower, and even olives. Vegetable oil is the label used to describe the array of oils derived from plants, including olive oil, sunflower oil, canola oil, soybean oil, and more. However, you will also find bottles of vegetable oil on your local supermarkets shelves.

Wesson and Crisco, for instance, both label their soy butter products vegetable oil, and Mazola uses vegetable oil + for their soy-canola blend. The United States Department of Agricultures specifications for margarine made with vegetable oils say the product must be made with either canola, safflower, sunflower, corn, soybean, or peanut oils in order to use the vegetable oil. While vegetable oil may refer to the type of oil directly made from one particular seed, nut, or fruit of a plant, it is also commonly labelled vegetable oil since it is a blend of several types of oils.

These oils are all listed in the ingredients, so consumers can switch among oil lists at will. These oils are very similar (all refined, all extremely mild in flavor, light in color) that it is very easy for them to swap with each other, with consumers not knowing the difference. Non-GMO vegetable oil is really a viable trade-off you can make, and still not have to modify your recipes; each oils flavor profile is extremely mild and light in color, so you do not really notice the difference in the end result. To replace the oil in your pie, you could use butter, avocado oil, or another fruit puree such as slices of avocado, crushed banana, or even apple sauce (note the differing flavour profiles for these fruits though, as it may alter how your pie tastes once cooked).

If you’re interested in Can You Eat Leftover Fish, take a look at my other article.

While completely fat-free replacements are incredible, keep in mind the absence of oil fats will give you a cake with denser texture. According to Bakestarters, canola oil is the best option to use when baking most cakes, as it does not impact the flavors of the pie at all, and it lets the other ingredients, such as chocolate or vanilla beans, shine. While both canola oil and vegetable oil really do taste slightly different, the results are going to be the same whenever you bake with either, whether you are roasting, sauteing, baking, etc.

Is canola or vegetable oil better for cake?

Vegetable oils work well for baking in general. Canola oil has the least flavor of all the vegetable oils, especially when used in baked goods. Canola oil is thought to have a neutral taste, allowing the flavor of your cake to come through.

Is there a difference between canola oil and vegetable oil?

There is a difference between canola and vegetable oil’s nutritional value. Even though both canola oil and vegetable oil are plant-based oils (canola comes from the rapeseed plant and vegetable oil from a soy-based plant), they differ in the fat quantities they contain.

Can canola oil be used in place of vegetable oil in baking?

Yes, you can easily replace vegetable oil with an equal measure of canola oil; just like vegetable oil, canola can add moisture and richness to your baked goods without affecting the flavor of your dish. Moreover, using canola in baking will prevent heart diseases as it is low in saturated fat and high in polyunsaturated fats.

Skip to content