Skip to Content

Can Carob Powder Be Substituted For Cocoa Powder

Can Carob Powder Be Substituted For Cocoa Powder

Carob powder may replace cocoa powder in recipes one-to-one, though it gives a subtler, roastier flavor. Carob powder can replace cocoa, and carob bars can be used in place of solid chocolate in almost all recipes.

If you are planning to use carob powder to make a banana bread that is choco-colored, for instance, you could replace 1/4 of the flour amount with carob. You can substitute cocoa powder with carob powder with the ratio 1 tbsp of cocoa to 2 tbsps of carob in any recipe, particularly for baking applications such as fixing dried cookie dough.

This means if when using cocoa powder as a carob replacement, you are giving your dishes an unmistakable chocolatey taste. Like cocoa powder, dark chocolate will give the deep, dark brown color that you would like in your carob replacement. If you would like the taste of chocolate without the bitterness, try using carob in place of cocoa powder.

Hot cocoa powder does not offer quite as much of an aroma as cocoa powder, but you can use hot cocoa powder as a substitute in many recipes. Hot cocoa mix has richer chocolate flavors and provides a thicker consistency than a hot cocoa mix.

Watch this video to learn about the use of Carob powder as a replacement for cocoa powder

If your recipe calls for cocoa powder, and you do not have any on hand, or cannot find it anywhere, you can use Dutch-processed cocoa, Carob Powder, Hot Cocoa Mix, or some of the following substitutions. Dutch-process cocoa, dark chocolate, Carob powder, unsweetened cooking chocolate, or some chocolates mentioned in this article are all good substitutes if you are trying to bake recipes.

Dark chocolate is another way of using products that come from cacao beans as a substitute for carob powder. In carob cookies recipes, you could also substitute carob powder with chocolate chips or substitute with hazelnuts. You can substitute for carob flour with dark chocolate, but keep in mind this trick is only for unsweetened chocolate.

Carob PowderCocoa Powder
Cocoa PowderCarob Powder
Instant CoffeeHot Chocolate Mix
Unsweetened Dark ChocolateHot Cocoa Mix
Substitutes for carob and cocoa powder.

If using Dutch-processed cocoa in a recipe where you have to raise it, such as in chocolate cakes, then incorporate some acidity to help with other leaving agents. If you are trying to use Dutch-processed cocoa as a substitute for baking soda in a recipe, you will have to add a little acidity to help with the leaving agents process, since Dutch-processed cocoa is not acidic like cocoa powder.

Instant coffee or espresso powder is not a good substitute for baking. Cocoa powder makes up a significant amount of the dry ingredients of the batter or dough. It is also known as bitter chocolate, mostly used to bake cakes, brownies, cookies, etc. It plays nearly the same role as cocoa powder, and does not sweeten the food. Cocoa Butter is used for the making of chocolate, cooking, and an ingredient for health and beauty products.

The usage is pretty close to using non-sweetened baking chocolate, but contains a little bit more fat since they both contain cacao butter. Unsweetened baking chocolate really has more fat content than cocoa powder, so you are going to want to use about one tablespoon less of butter or shortening (whichever fats your recipe calls for). The best way to use unsweetened chocolate is when mixing the sugar and butter together in the recipe.

If you’re interested in Can You Substitute Cook And Serve Pudding For An Instant In A Recipe, take a look at my other article

If you are using quality dark chocolate, then you will not need to use as much sugar in your recipes as it has very little sugar. Sweetened milk chocolate is regular chocolate you would consume; it is the most convenient version of cacao that you can obtain. Bitter chocolate contains potassium, carbohydrates, protein, caffeine, calcium, fat, iron, magnesium, dietary fiber, and more. To use this unsweetened chocolate as a replacement for cocoa powder, you would need to add an ounce of unsweetened chocolate to three tablespoons of cocoa powder. If using this substitute in a recipe that calls for baking soda, add an eighth teaspoon of cream of tartar, white vinegar, or lemon juice for each three tablespoons of cocoa powder called for.

Carob Powder or Carob Chips: If you are looking for a non-sweetened cocoa powder substitute because you are allergic to chocolate or are sensitive to caffeine, use equal amounts of Carob Powder. Carob powder can be used in any recipe that includes cacao, from steaming cups of hot chocolate, to brownies, protein truffles, homemade cocoa, and beyond. The fine powder is sold either plain or as a Carob Bar or Carob Chips, which are a replacement for chocolate bars and chocolate chips, respectively. While carob powder is certainly less popular than cacao, do not let this fool you into thinking it is some strange, difficult, and expensive ingredient only used by vegans.

While carob powder has a similar look to cacao powder–it is made from beans of the cacao tree (Theobroma cacao L.)–it has a mellower, sweeter flavor, and offers a dramatically different nutritional profile. Carob is easily the most popular natural replacement product for products derived from Theobroma cacao, the tree from which cocoa beans are harvested. Cacao, used for making chocolate, comes from pods from Theobroma cacao plants, while carob comes from the pods of a Mediterranean perennial tree. In fact, Cupuacu is a Brazilian fruit derived from a plant of the cacao family, and it shares many similarities with cocoa, of course, as well as with carob.

Although it is from the cacao family, carob is not like cacao in the sense of not having any addictive caffeine. Unlike chocolate, carob contains no stimulant alkaloids, which is why it did not cause me any caffeine-jitters. I was pleasantly surprised to find that it has a mellower, sweeter taste, which is less bitter than chocolate. It is important to keep in mind that carob is higher in carbohydrates and sweetness, so use a lower quantity than you would with cacao.

While you could definitely substitute carob powder for cocoa, the flavors are different enough that you probably will have to adjust the ratios and the sugars in order for the carob to mesh into the recipe better. Carob powder does not have the same rich, chocolatey taste as cacao, and using it instead of cacao powder in a recipe is likely to result in a less-flavorful outcome.

If you’re interested in Can You Eat After Using Whitening Strips, take a look at my other article

Instant coffee might not offer the deep, rich brown color that you associate with cacao and cocoa powder, but it still offers strong flavors with a slight bitter edge. The trick to making this taste like chocolate is by adding one to two teaspoons of instant coffee (or coffee substitutes, like coffee powders made from barley or chicory, sold at health food stores and in some supermarkets).

Is carob powder better than cocoa?

Carob is obtained from a different species of tree, Ceratonia siliqua. Carob powder is higher in carbohydrates and sugar, lower in fat, and higher in fiber than cocoa powder. It also contains more minerals than cacao. Carob does not contain any theobromine or caffeine but usually has fewer stimulants.

How to use carob powder?

Carob powder is a healthy and delicious alternative to cocoa powder. It can be used in many different ways, from baking to making hot chocolate. Here are some tips on how to use carob powder in your cooking and baking. When baking, carob powder can be used as a direct replacement for cocoa powder.

Does carob powder taste like cocoa powder?

Carob is sweeter and less bitter than chocolate, although tasting comparable. The powder is similar to cocoa powder in texture and has a toasted taste – it can be used in replacement of cocoa powder in many places. It is added to beverages, desserts, and other foods rather than being consumed alone.