Skip to Content

Can Butter Be Substituted For Vegetable Oil

Can Butter Be Substituted For Vegetable Oil

Can Butter Be Substituted For Vegetable Oil?

You can replace butter with vegetable oil. Use the exact amount determined in the directions (e.g., if it calls for 1/3 cup of oil, use 5 1/3 tablespoons of butter). Melt it down, and then let it chill for a bit. Use away!

Vegetable oil can replace butter most of the time. But it is important to know what purpose the butter serves in the recipe for which you are looking to replace it. It may sound impossible, but it is actually possible to replace butter with oil in nearly every kind of recipe. When baking, you will want to replace the vegetable oil or butter, and you can use either vegetable shortening or Crisco instead.

You can substitute three-quarters cup vegetable oil for each cup of butter called for. If your recipe calls for 1 cup butter, replace it with 1/2 cup of oil, adding the liquid as you go, until your dough comes together and looks adequately moist. If the recipe calls for eight tablespoons of butter, substitute six tablespoons of olive oil.

You can include extra virgin olive oil in baked recipes calling for butter, and you automatically make the recipe healthier, as olive oil is lower in saturated fats than butter. You will need to add the olive oil carefully in your recipes using the ratio that three parts extra virgin olive oil is equivalent to four parts butter. There is really no hard-and-fast rule on how much butter you should substitute with oil, but generally speaking, you can use around three-quarters the amount of butter the recipe calls for.

Watch this video to learn about the difference in baking of cake in butter and vegetable oil

With a similar properties that make it solid when cold, liquid when hot, J. Schatzel has found that coconut oil is a successful substitute when using the same amount of the oil as the amount of butter called for in a recipe. J. Schatzel will simply combine butter and oil with wet ingredients to bake, or you could likely combine it with sugar called for, and blend as directed otherwise in the recipe. To replace butter for oil in baked goods, simply melt the butter, measure out, allow it to cool, and then add as you would the oil.

The differences between butter and oil are what makes substitutions possible, but also make them a bit more difficult. There are recipes out there that butter will perform just as well as butter, but there are places that are just not a great idea for that substitution. If you are dairy-free, or you are simply looking for another flavor, you can substitute butter with oil for most recipes as well, but keeping flavor in mind is key.

Oil does not also work well in recipes like cookies and cakes, which require creaming or mixing butter first with sugar and eggs. If your recipe calls for just melting butter, you stand a better chance of getting similar results using oil instead. If you are cooking for dinner, and the recipe calls for melting butter in the pot, simply use equal amounts of cooking oil.

Most recipes call for using butter in a stir-fry or sauteing vegetables, and you can use butter just like butter in soup. Another viable alternative to cooking oil is avocado oil, as you can use it to deep-fry, saute, bake, and anything else. If you are making something that is more flavorful, such as salad dressing or stir-fries, you can use olive oil as a 1 to 1 replacement for vegetable oil. The beauty of butter substitutes for baked goods is you have a little bit more flexibility because you do not need to match the higher smoke point of your vegetable oil (as in baking).

Bakes such as quick breads and muffins are two recipes in which an oil substitute is a great idea, and they will yield results that are quite similar to the original recipe.

It is best to use vegetable oil instead of butter in cases where the butter is intended to be used in the form of melting, such as in muffins, quick breads, and when frying vegetables. Using vegetable oil as an alternative in recipes calling for softened butter is discouraged, particularly in baking, where combining the butter with sugar is a crucial step in developing a crumbs texture. Because the amount of fat in a loaf or pie will influence the way that it rises, the closest butter alternative is a high saturated fat oil like coconut or palm oil. It is actually hard to use coconut oil as a substitute for butter, either, for flaky pastries and cookies such as ladyfinger, croissants, or anything that has a thin, flaky layer.

For things meant to be flaky and dry, it is easiest to just stick to butter (no pun intended), but you can create a non-dairy version by substituting in coconut oil. To replace the oil in a pie, you could use butter, avocado oil, or another fruit pulp such as slices of avocado, crushed banana, or even apple sauce (note the differing flavour profiles of these fruits though, as it may alter how the pie tastes once cooked). For most sweet recipes, you will want to use light-tasting oil, but chocolate recipes, such as chocolate cakes, will be better served with heavier oils such as olive oil and avocado. You can use melted coconut oil or butter as a 1 to 1 replacement for vegetable oils in baked goods, such as muffins, cakes, and cookies.

You can substitute with dairy butter, a vegan alternative to butter, or margarine using the suggested oil amounts. A good rule of thumb is to consider margarine as an oil: You may substitute it best with the oil melted.

One of our favourite, easiest substitutions is simply using olive oil for smearing the bread with rather than butter. J. Schatzel, though, has found that olive oil is a delicious butter replacement for the crusts that I use for meat or pot pie (and my very picky-eating husband has not noticed the difference!).

If you are worried about keeping a dishes flavor intact (J. Schatzel found that the substitutions above did not change the flavor, but my husband swears that he can tell the difference when I use anything other than that substitute), using 1/4 cup of unsweetened apple sauce and 1/4 cup of buttermilk to replace one cup of butter called for in a recipe works fine. For the following substitutes, J. Schatzel was able to successfully substitute 100% of the butter in the recipe.

Using vegetable oil instead of some–or all–of the butter that you normally use could be a heart-healthy shift to your diet, according to the American Heart Association. Using butter instead of butter is trickier for pie crusts or scones, because those types of recipes rely on little bits of solid butter to make pockets of air, says Amy Shapiro, RDN, CDN, the founder of Real Nutrition, in New York. I love using oils such as vegetable or canola oil in recipes such as Pandan Waffles, Crispy Belgian Waffles, or Ube Waffles, as they are neutral in flavour and produce similar results.

What is better using butter or oil for baking?

 Research says that butter contains “bad” cholesterol that is risky for the heart instead of vegetable oil. The cakes made with oil are in general superior to the cakes made with butter. The texture of both seems to be different in the cake mix. Oil-based cakes tend to bake up loftier, and stay moist and tender far longer than cakes made with butter.

Can you substitute butter for oil when frying?

You may use butter in straightforward pan-fried meals, yes! Similar to sautéing, you should gradually melt the butter and allow the moisture to evaporate before adding your meal. In butter, you cannot deep fry. It simply cannot withstand the heat; it will burn and brown before you reach temperatures suitable for deep-frying.

Is it healthy to reuse frying oil?

Oil becomes more mutagenic as a result. Reusing cooking oil when preparing meals can increase the body’s level of free radicals, which can lead to inflammation, the main factor in the development of most illnesses like diabetes, heart disease, and obesity. High bodily inflammation might lower immunity and make you more susceptible to diseases.